CAC Certified Coins

To Order: Contact Matt (917-727-1893) or Darrell (929-322-4953) by phone, or email using the shopping cart ()

About CAC Coins: John Albanese efforts to identify above average coins in Third Party Grading service holders is having a significant impact within the numismatic marketplace. Coins designated with the Green Bean easily bring full trend guide pricing along with premiums. Astute collectors are demanding only CAC validated coins for long term collecting objectives and sound financial holdings.

This price list features only Gerry Fortin Rare Coins inventory that has CAC approval. Look for the icon by individual listings.

 

There are 201 Coins for Sale. New coin(s) added on October 11, 2026

Photo Type Date Grade TPG Variety GFRC Rating Price Description Buy
Half & 1 Cent
Early Copper 1C 1820 Early Copper 1820
Large Date
MS65+BN
NGC
6329497008
N-13
Gem $2950 New August 19! Dazzling Luster with Attractive Toning. This large cent has wonderful eye appeal. The luster is excellent and accentuates the blue and magenta toning seen throughout the coin. There is a huge die crack on the obverse that connects the stars and date together. Miss Liberty's cheek is clean. Without some spots in Miss Liberty's hair, this coin would grade even higher.
Flying Eagle 1C 1857 Flying Eagle 1857
MS63
PCGS
41703694

Choice $1695 New August 18! Steely Reflective Luster, Wicked Nice Eye Appeal, CAC Approval. Ex. Evergreen and Sooner Collections. A thoroughly pleasing 1857 Flying Eagle strike that presents sharp steely fields with substantial reflectance. Surfaces are unabraded with a hint of obverse verdigris at the legend and date punch. Reverse strike is weak at the upper right wreath. Overall, the eye appeal is wicked nice and certain to please the advanced collector. Recently upgraded by the Sooner Collection and back on the price list. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval.
Flying Eagle 1C 1858 Flying Eagle 1858
J-193
PF61
PCGS OGH
1457845
J-193
Choice $2500 New August 18! 1858 Pattern Flying Eagle Cent. J-193. Ex. Humphreys Collection. The obverse is the regular-issue Small Letters 1858 cent. The reverse resembles the as-issued 1860 Indian cent with an oak wreath and ONE CENT with a shield at the top, but the shield is much broader and ornamental. Struck in copper-nickel with a plain edge. Excellent eye appeal despite a fair number of hairlines and a few spots. The mirrors are strong and the red mauve toning is very pretty. Housed in a PCGS Gen. 3.0 holder (Jan 1990 - Feb 1993).
Flying Eagle 1C 1858 Flying Eagle 1858
Small Letters
MS63
PCGS
36364603

Gem $1950 New August 19! Well Struck with Excellent Original Luster. Ex. Evergreen. Dazzling original luster excites the eyes on this well struck example. There are no noticeable marks. The PCGS label says this is a Small Letters variety. There is also an Eagle Eye sticker and a Snow-13 designation which is a Large Letter variety which looks to be incorrect as it is a Small Letters variety.
Indian 1C 1859 Indian 1859
MS63
NGC
8424905012

Choice $1095 Great Color, Clean Surfaces. This is an eye appealing example of the first year of the Indian cent type. Excellent red orange color with nice luster. A few small specks keeps this from a gem rating.
Indian 1C 1899 Indian 1899
PF67RB
PCGS
50481396

Choice $5450 Almost Fully Red. This nicely struck proof displays attractive color. The obverse is mostly red with deeper magenta color on the left which likely prevented the coin from being designated as fully red. The right obverse is flashy with orange color mellowing to yellowish green towards the rim. The reverse is fully red. None of the small specks are distracting.
Lincoln 1C 1914 Lincoln 1914
PF64RB
PCGS
84101387

Choice $1400 New September 10! Near Gem. Excellent Color and Surfaces. Gorgeous iridescent red brown toning sparkles with underlying luster. The fields are smooth with few defects. Well struck with all design elements fully formed. Looks better than a 64.
Image Available Soon Lincoln 1958
Lot of 52 1934-1958 Lincoln 1c CACG-65RD
MS65RD
CACG

Choice HOLD
$1890
Sold from Daily Blog. CAC Endorsement
5 Cents
Capped Bust 5C 1834 Capped Bust 1834
MS65
PCGS
26130192
LM-2
Gem $4450 Superb Toning; Hammered Strike. This gem Capped Bust half dime has everything going for it - fantastic luster underlying grey blue multicolored toning over mark free surfaces. The strike is exceptional as well with each star coming to a point and outstanding detail on the eagles feathers and talons.
Seated 5C 1837 Seated 1837
Small Date
AU58
NGC
348522012

Gem $1450 Wow! For the Color Connoisseur. First Year Type. Gorgeous dual-side toning provides superb eye appeal on this first year of issue of this No Stars type half dime. Vibrant blue toning surrounds light magenta color. Well struck with a whisper of wear. There is an interesting cud forming on the first A in AMERICA on the reverse. Light handling lines can be seen on the obverse fields but are hidden beneath the very attractive toning.
Seated 5C 1838 Seated 1838
MS65
PCGS
25351181

Choice $1895 Near Gem. Atrractive Stars, No Drapery Type.. Surfaces are original with a few ticks on either side. The obverse is well struck with eye appealing toning and is gem quality. The obverse center is mostly copper toned with tints of blue and magenta at the date and yellow blue near stars 1-8. The reverse is well struck except for the A in HALF.
Seated 5C 1838 Seated 1838
No Drapery, Large Stars
MS64
NGC
2685622002

Choice $1285 Creamy Frosted Luster, Complete Strike, Near-Gem, CAC Approved. 2025 Black Friday Sale Offering - A boldly repunched star 8 is readily evident on this superbly preserved 1838 Seated half dime. Radiant mint bloom radiates creamy frosted luster when placed under angled lighting. Strike is fully executed with a reverse die crack through O(F) into the wreath. One reverse field mark holds this piece back from potential higher grade. The eye appeal is certainly there. Newly consigned and a premium example. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Seated 5C 1838 Seated 1838
Large Stars
MS64
NGC
4337155009

Gem $1200 New October 1! Gem with Nice Toning. This tiny coin has a lot of appeal. Fully struck with very few marks for the grade. Attractive toning with pink and green toning on the obverse with more green on the reverse. Some small rim cuds on the obverse with the usual clash marks on the reverse.
Seated 5C 1839 Seated 1839
MS64
NGC
2037603041

Choice $1195 New October 1! Ex. Col. Green/Newman with Attractive Toning. Another gorgeous early Seated half dime. This one is from the Newman collection and has interesting and attractive blue green toning with patches of silver grey. The strike is good.
Seated 5C 1843 Seated 1843
MS66
PCGS
13718953

Gem $2750 Beautiful toning; shattered reverse. Excellent luster underlying golden rust toning at the centers with blue toning at the obverse periphery creates excellent eye appeal on this early Seated half dime. With only 9 stickered at CAC in 66 with none higher, this pop top half dime would be a great addition to a collector putting together a high grade set or would make an excellent type coin. The shattered reverse die creates additional interest.
Seated 5C 1846 Seated 1846
EF45
CACG
41371215

Choice $6950 Key Date! Good Detail, Unmarked Surfaces. Ex. Hilt Collection. Just 27,000 minted of this lowest minted date in the Stars on Obverse type. The next smallest mintage date is the 1853 No Arrows with a mintage of 135,000. What stands out is how smooth the surfaces are. The coin displays good detail with nice even wear. CAC has endorsed 4 at this grade, with just 5 higher. The CACG holder indicates this with a (L)egacy designation.
Seated 5C 1850 Seated 1850
MS64
PCGS
28665988

Choice $850 New September 25! Fully Struck with Good Originality. Ex. Sooner Collection. Fully struck with a clean obverse that grades MS65 on its own. Good originality is seen which makes the luster slightly muted. There is a hard to see thin pinscratch on the reverse above A in HALF going to the right cereal wreath to the topmost berry that takes this coin to an MS64.
Seated 5C 1853 Seated 1853
Arrows
MS67
CACG
648509387

Gem $12950 Original surfaces; High Grade Type Coin. CAC has only endorsed 9 coins at the Supberb Gem MS67 level of this three year type coin. This coin is original with highly lustrous undipped off white surfaces. It is nicely struck and clean. Some die clashing can be seen on the reverse.
Seated 5C 1860 Seated 1860
MS67
PCGS
25252064

Gem $2300 New September 28! Superb Gem with Great Color. Wow! This small coin packs a lot of punch. Golden grey with shades of peach and sea green. Fully struck with pristine surfaces and bold luster. A superb type coin or for a top shelf date set.
Shield 5C 1881 Shield 1881
EF40
NGC
3746119020

Choice $825 Semi-key Date. Just 68,000 business strikes were minted of this scarce date. It displays nice originality with a smooth evenly worn obverse. The reverse has some older scattered marks in the open field surrounding the 5 and near the last A in America.
Liberty V 5C 1886 Liberty V 1886
MS63
PCGS OGH
7264188

Choice $2700 New October 1! OGH. Well Struck and Lustrous. One of the three best dates in the Liberty nickel series. Well struck, lustrous with few marks. The grade is limited by a series of mint made planchet imperfections on the lower half of the obverse. Without the planchet imperfections, this coin would certainly grade higher. In a PCGS Gen. 3.0 (1990-1993) OGH holder.
Liberty V 5C 1909 Liberty V 1909
PF67CAM
PCGS
50062136

Gem $2750 New August 19! Attractively Toned on Both Sides.. It is unusual to find a nicely toned Liberty nickel with a cameo designation. The rims have bluish toning while the center is magenta on both sides. The toning doesn't impact the deeply mirrored fields that contrast nicely with Miss Liberty. Hairlines are not to be found. In a PCGS Gen. 4.1 (2002-2004) holder.
Buffalo 5C 1914D Buffalo 1914-D
AU58
CACG
53871921

Gem $650 Strictly Original and Nicely Struck. Few Marks. The 1914-D Buffalo nickel is one of the best dates in a circulated Buffalo nickel collection. This coin is strictly original and perfectly graded. It is nicely struck and has very few marks for an AU58. This kind of quality in an AU58 is hard to find which is what we seek relentlessly. The CACG holder does have some haze near LIBERTY on the obverse.
Buffalo 5C 1937 Buffalo 1937
Three Legs
VF25
CACG
533236419

Gem $1400 New October 11! Fantastic Eye Appeal; Popular Three Leg. Ex. Humphreys Collection The three legged Buffalo is as popular as ever. This CACG VF 25, just back from grading, is original as they come with great surface quality and a toning pattern which brings out all the design elements which are well struck. Almost medallic in appearance, this coin has excellent eye appeal.
10 Cents
Draped Bust 10C 1798/7 Draped Bust 1798/7
13 Stars Reverse
EF45
PCGS
12534347
JR-2
Choice $42000 New August 22! Extremely Rare Variety; Only 5 CAC'd; Original Silver Grey Patina. Silver-gray surfaces with hints of rose patina as the coin turns under a light. A bit softly struck in the centers, there are a few abrasions that are consistent with the grade and heavy die clashing in the obverse fields characteristic of all known examples. One scratch mark parallels Liberty's bust to 5 o'clock on the obverse rim. This is one of the rarest redbook varieties of Draped Bust dimes with approximately 30 examples known, The CAC population in all grades is 5, with this one being the lowest. There is one in 58, two in 62 and one in 63. The 63 CAC sold in 2015 for $199,750. The two 62 CACs would likely cost in excess of $100k assuming one became available. The 58 CAC is locked up in my (Matt's) collection. This coin was sold by Stacks in August 2013 for $30,555. This is a rare chance to obtain a CAC'd collector grade example of this rare date.
Capped Bust 10C 1821 Capped Bust 1821
Small Date
MS62
PCGS
50984623
JR-9
Gem $5250 New August 21! Gem at Grade, Steely-Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels. Ex. Evergreen and Osprey Collections. The steely frosted fields on this GFRC-Gem rated 1821 JR-9 dime are captivating. A stunning open collar Capped Bust dime that would be ideal for type or placement in an advanced date set. Under angled lighting, the luster is sharp and brilliant with swirling cartwheels adding to the viewing pleasure. A complete strike, with meticulously defined hair curls and elevated start center points, further enhances the presentation. Surfaces are essentially unabraded with two well hidden hairlines on the lower obverse that warrant mention and most likely correlate to the certified grade. However, the eye appeal is that of a higher grade.
Seated 10C 1821 Seated 1821
Large Date
VF35
PCGS
26810131
JR-7
R2
Choice $595 Smooth Original Coin. An appealing original Capped Bust dime with no major marks. The lettering on the reverse is particularly interesting due to the "S OF" letters in STATES OF AMERICA being noticeably higher than the other letters and the unusually large C in AMERICA.
Capped Bust 10C 1830 Capped Bust 1830
Small 10C
MS63
PCGS
45657036
JR-2
Choice $3850 New September 28! Lustrous; Cool Die Cracks. Ex. Evergreen Collection. Both sides are well struck and exhibit frosty luster with the reverse having a bit more toning. Marks are consistent with the grade none of which is individually mentionalble. Interesting die cracks on the reverse, with a crack from the rim through the first S in States to the scroll and another heavier one through the leaves.
Capped Bust 10C 1831 Capped Bust 1831
MS64
PCGS
35587394
JR-5
Gem $4950 New August 22! Gem Original wuth Attractive Toning. Ex. Evergreen. Orange-gold toning covers lustrous grey surfaces. Perfectly original and very clean for the grade.
Capped Bust 10C 1836 Capped Bust 1836
MS62+
PCGS
45581349
JR-1
Gem $2500 New September 28! Gem Original. A beautiful Capped Bust dime with beautiful iridescent grey surfaces with lots of frosty luster. Marks are at a minimum and Miss Liberty's portrait is especially mark free. A die crack from the cap to star 8. Has the appeal of a higher grade.
Seated 10C 1837 Seated 1837
No Stars, Small Date
MS65
PCGS
21314594
F-104
Gem HOLD
$12900
New August 21! No Stars, Small Date, Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection.. Ex. Evergreen and Gerry Fortin Collections. An extraordinary gem in all regards as both sides are draped in warm frosted luster with rose-red and sea-green toning. The surfaces are fully pristine other than a single tick to the left of the clasp. The reverse was previously clashed with a Large Date obverse and presents die clash marks below DI(ME) and across the ribbons and stems. The Small Date punch can be easily distinguished by a round top 7 digit. The Small Date is the better of the two 1837 date punch varieties with the CAC census reported at 76 examples with only five finer. Heritage Auctions, 2003 Long Beach Sale, Lot #330. Housed in original PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4562.
Seated 10C 1838 Seated 1838
Large Stars
MS66
CACG
498456108
F-113
Gem $6500 New September 14! Reverse Die Flaw, Second Pairing, Gem Original,. This richly original example features blended steel-gray and champagne-pink patina on both sides. Strike is hammered with high relief stars regardless of the dies being significant eroded. Silky luster manages to radiate through a fairly thick patina. Surfaces are entirely unabraded and smooth and. The F-113 attribution points (reverse die flaw and die erosion below date) are easily seen. A well preserved candidate to represent the short lived No Drapery design in a high grade Mint State type set.
Seated 10C 1838 Seated 1838
No Drapery, Large Stars
MS65
PCGS
6617309
F-104
Gem $13500 New August 21! Large Stars, Gem Original. Ex. Evergreen and Gerry Fortin Collections. This 1838 Large Stars was among the numerous Gold CAC approved dimes within the Fortin Collection. Though overshadowed by three significantly shattered obverse dies, the F-104 obverse is also a compelling study with bold die crack through the rock and shield along with a second through star 9 and into the right field. This example radiates frosted luster from undisturbed surfaces with pastel sea-green and golden toning on the obverse and sky blue hues on the reverse. Cartwheels are equally impressive. Acquired during May, 2003 from the popular Teletrade platform. With its Gold CAC bean, this dime has claims to the condition census as the CAC population is 9 total at the MS66 and MS67 grades. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) Gold Shield holder with Gold CAC approval. PCGS #4568.
Seated 10C 1839O Seated 1839-O
No Drapery
VG10
PCGS
37211498
F-109
R6
Choice $550 New October 1! Very Rare! Huge O Obverse, F-109 Small O Reverse, Natural Gray Toning, Choice. This is the third time that GFRC has handled this dime. As Gerry mentioned previously, "I've seen few 1839-O F-109 examples in any grade during my two decades plus of working with Seated dimes. The F-109 variety results from the pairing of "Huge O" obverse with another Small O reverse; its origins are not well understood to this day. The reverse exhibits a small O mintmark but from a different style punch fr0m previously documented dies of that year. The F-109 die pairing is the last use of the "Huge O" obverse die as most of the lower devices are effaced at this point." The coin itself is very original with attractive grey surfaces and few marks. The Seated dime variety specialist is advised to act quickly on this one.
Seated 10C 1840 Seated 1840
No Drapery
AU55
PCGS
54100761
F-103
Gem $750 Gem Original, Chin Whiskers Variety, Unique Toning. Ex. Hawk Farm Collection. A popular Top 100 variety with heavy die polish lines from Liberty's chin to bare shoulder, thus the name Chin Whiskers. This CAC'd example has nice grey toning over very clean surfaces. A splash of colorful toning around Miss Liberty's head makes this coin memorable. Both sides show slight softness of strike including the O of ONE on the reverse.
Seated 10C 1840O Seated 1840-O
No Drapery
EF40
NGC
6924959008
F-106
Choice $950 Medium O, Top 100 Varieties #16, Choice Original Surfaces. 1840 New Orleans strikes are challenging in original EF or better grades. Three mintmark sizes are available with the F-106 variety resulting from a single Medium O reverse die. An early die state reverse without the vertical die crack at noon, but exhibiting the usual weakness at (ON)E. A nice original CACd example with classic grey surfaces with darker peripheries.
Seated 10C 1841 Seated 1841
MS65
PCGS
50023838
F-104
Gem $12750 New August 21! Repunched 184, Exceptional Gem, Condition Rarity. Ex. Evergreen and Gerry Fortin Collections. A richly and colorfully toned dime that is a condition rarity with a strike that is complete. It is important to note that strike variations often plagued the With Stars design. The eye appeal is exceptional with a partially mirrored obverse and frosted reverse. Apricot-gray, blue, and golden-orange shades decorate the obverse while slate-gray gives way to orange-tinged borders on the reverse. The surfaces are entirely unabraded and a joy during 10x inspection. The repunching below the 184 digits is boldly defined while the reverse die is pristine prior to becoming excessively rusted during later usage. Heritage Auctions, November 2002, Santa Clara CA Sale, Lot #6048. Housed in its original PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder with Gold CAC approval. PCGS #4579.
Seated 10C 1842 Seated 1842
MS65+
PCGS
42075540

Choice $4500 Near Gem. Sole PCGS MS65+. Strict Originaltiy. Ex. Hawk Farm Collection. This is the only PCGS MS65+ coin with just six coins graded higher. Strictly original, this coin is well struck with good surfaces. The obverse is original grey and mark free. The reverse is easily gem quality with attractive light blue and magenta color in the centers with yellow orange toning towards the rims.
Seated 10C 1842 Seated 1842
MS66
PCGS
43190533
F-105
Gem HOLD
$6750
New August 21! Tied for Finest, Gem Original. Ex. Evergreen and Gerry Fortin Collections. "Luster bomb" best describes this 1842 as granular mint frost is pervasive on both sides. Under a bright light, the frosted radiance is intense and thoroughly satisfying. The strike is deeply impressed with a complete head, elevated scroll edges, and fully detailed wreath leaves. Faint gold is noted within the obverse center and is amplified by the photography. The CAC census is reported at 40 total with five approved at the certified grade and none finer. Privately acquired from the Newtown Collection during early 2023. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4581.
Seated 10C 1842O Seated 1842-O
MS63
PCGS
2709936
F-105
Choice $6600 New August 20! Choice Original. Ex. Evergreen and Tenafly Collections. Silver gray surfaces are uniformly shaded to the naked eye, though under a glass a few bits of crust are evident on both sides. Luster is a consistent with the grade, and a touch sharper on the reverse. F-105, with a die lump inside of star 12, and a slightly upward sloping date. The survival of Branch Mint coinage in this level of preservation was strictly a matter of chance, as little attention was paid to mintmarks until the end of the 19th century. A quick glance at the Guide Book confirms this, with prices rapidly increasing at the EF and AU levels. This piece approaches the condition census, as PCGS reports seven pieces finer, none higher than MS65. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder with CAC approval. While this coin is by no means inexpensive, it remains close to finest known, and will sell at a fraction of the price of a Gem Uncirculated example. From the Jones Beach Collection (Heritage 1/2007, lot 2565, realized $4,600). PCGS #4582.
Seated 10C 1845 Seated 1845
MS64+
PCGS
24705269
F-110
Gem $3500 New August 23! Gem Original. Ex. Evergreen and Gerry Fortin Collections. A colorful 1845 F-110 specimen that is the sole MS64+ example certified. The GFRC-Gem quality rating is appropriate for this well balanced offering. Steely-frosted radiance is showcased by light copper gold and sea-green on the obverse rims. The sea-green toning extends to the reverse with deeper copper-gold throughout. As with nearly all Fortin Collection coins, the strike is complete with strong stars, head details, and complete wreath leaves. F-110, a third die marriage of Obverse 1 with a reverse die that exhibits deep die lines through AM(ER)ICA. Utilized as the plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Nine are CAC approved at the offered grade with four finer. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.5 (2011-2013) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4586.
Seated 10C 1850 Seated 1850
MS63
PCGS
58327420

Gem HOLD
$1075
New October 2! Gem Original; Beautiful Subtle Color. Light grey obverse with baby blue toning in the fields around the base of Miss Liberty. The reverse is iridescent gray, with shades of pale green and pink. The coin has satiny luster and has very few marks. A gem.
Seated 10C 1852O Seated 1852-O
MS62
PCGS
28148598
F-101
Choice $3950 New August 20! Challenging New Orleans Date, Hammered Strike, Unquestionably Choice. Ex. Evergreen and New Orleans Collections. Only 31 have been stickered in all grades with Mint State examples amounting to slightly more than a handful. This MS62 example presents a hammered strike with every device intricately detailed including bold die chips surrounding stars 3 through 5. The surfaces are frosted with a natural light gray patina on both sides. A 10x inspection found unblemished surfaces with two obverse rim exclusions as made. This is worthy of belonging in an advanced collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1858 Seated 1858
PR66
PCGS
81482044

Gem $5650 Scarce Proof Date, Single Finer, Brilliant Mirrors, Evergreen State Collection. A glittering, reflective proof dime with a large amount of cameo contrast. Rose-gold and blues decorate the obverse while the reverse exhibits center aquamarine surrounded by rose and gold intermixed hues. A hammered strike further establishes GFRC-Gem eye appeal. 1858 was the first year of "official" public proof sales by the Mint. Although Breen estimated just 80 proofs issued and later estimates suggested 100 or so proofs. PCGS estimates 50-70 are known, however, few if any are the equal of this gleaming example. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with special D.L. Hansen pedigree label and CAC approval. An important Evergreen State Collection release.
Seated 10C 1859O Seated 1859-O
AU55
CACG
15599188

Choice HOLD
$625
New October 8! Near Gem, Great Eye Appeal. This near gem has beautiful semi-relective grey surfaces with excellent luster and only a hint of wear. It has darker toning around the stars and legends on the reverse. The eye appeal is excellent.
Seated 10C 1860 Seated 1860
PR65+CAM
PCGS
25619936
F-101
Gem $2665 Superb Gem Type 1 Obverse Presentation, Brilliant Reflective Mirrors, Tenafly Collection. Final Consignor Price Reduction! - What a pleasure to be again offering this magnificent 1860 proof strike that originated from the Washington State Collection. 1860 brought 1,000 proof strike with the newly engraved and hubbed Type 1 obverse design per Longacre-Paquet. The design proved to be unpopular due to rapid wear of the high points and a flat overall appearance. When examining this piece, one of the finer extant, the intricate device details become apparent. I promptly noted that Liberty's legs and breasts are quite elevated as compared to the low relief head details. Fields are brilliant reflective and surround frosted motifs. The Cameo eye appeal is thoroughly pleasing. If attempting to build a Liberty Seated dime proof set collection (1856-1891), this example will set the bar for premium quality and warrants a strong bid. CAC has approved 6 at the PR65 grade with eight finer. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #84753.
Seated 10C 1864 Seated 1864
MS66
PCGS
35690560
F-102a
Gem $15000 Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Lightly mirrored, reflective luster penetrates the thick colorful toning of this Civil War piece. Aqua and russet patina predominate, with neon shades additionally present above the figure of Liberty. F-101a, with a defect at the upper right of O(NE), the same reverse die as used in 1863. Clashing is evident beneath DIME. This piece is tied for finest known at CAC with three other pieces. The overall CAC population is 24 pieces, and the CAC price guide is $7,200. Ex. GFRC. This piece represent yet another exceptional gem from the Newtown consignor, a pedigree that will long be remembered among Seated dime specialists. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1865 Seated 1865
PF66CAM
PCGS
45275848
F-102
Choice $6500 New October 1! Finest Known Cameo Proof Endorsed by CAC. Attractive Rim Toning with Cameo Devices. Ex. Evergreen Collection. This is the sole finest of 8 proof cameos that have been endorsed by CAC. Well struck cameo devices are surrounded by attractive blue and magenta rim toning. One lint mark can be seen near the right facing wrist of Miss Liberty.
Seated 10C 1867 Seated 1867
MS67
PCGS
38519788
F-102
Gem $21000 New August 21! Tied for Finest, An Exceptional Gem. Ex. Evergreen and Gerry Fortin Collections. 1867 brought the lowest Philadelphia mintage with 6,000 struck. Mint State survivors are available in all grades with this lot being tied for finest at PCGS and CAC. An exceptional example with intense prooflike reflectance and colorful rose shaded centers surrounded by peripheral blues as struck with conspicuously striated dies. Partial wire rims are noted with a full obverse strike and near complete reverse other than the upper left wheat grains. F-102, with business strike from a single die pairing with a heavily clashed obverse only. Acquired via private treaty with no known auction records, though the lot is featured as the PCGS price guide plate coin. A side-by-side comparison with the Simpson specimen could be a revealing exercise. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4645.
Seated 10C 1870 Seated 1870
MS65
PCGS
46135623
F-101
Choice $3250 Better Date. The Only 1870 Dime in MS65 Endorsed by CAC. From the Indiana collection. The CAC population report shows a total of 26 endorsed by CAC in all grades. This is the only MS65 endorsed by CAC with four endorsed at the MS66 level. This highly lustrous coin is mostly brilliant white. The obverse is well struck with smooth fields. The reverse has some strike weakness on the upper left stalk.
Seated 10C 1873 Seated 1873
No Arrows, Open 3
MS63
PCGS
85794205
F-101
Choice $2600 New August 20! Open 3, Choice Original. Ex. Evergreen and Massachusetts Collections. The 1873 No Arrows Open 3 date continues to be underrated for its overall scarcity. It just does not garner an respect and is the Rodney Dangerfield of the dime series. The PCGS and CDN price guides are much too conservative given that only 19 are stickered with four better and the finest MS65 Fortin specimen realizing $13,500 at auction. This F-101 example exhibits thick frosted luster and a complete strike. Light gold patina is evident on both sides. Circular die cracks throughout the wreath exactly match those for the F-101 Liberty Seated dime die variety plate coin. This near-gem example offers old time eye appeal at a fair reserve. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4660.
Seated 10C 1874S Seated 1874-S
With Arrows
AU55
PCGS
19290730
F-102
R4
Choice $1500 New October 1! Small Thin S, Choice Original, Golden Brown Patina, Accurately Graded. Ex. Cleveland, Tenafly, and Under Construction Collections. A thoroughly wholesome 1874 San Francisco strike with Small Thin S reverse. Surfaces retain active luster under the golden brown colors. Toning that is uniform across obverse and reverse. When viewed under a bright light, surfaces offer gun metal blue on the obverse. Strike is better than average but with weakness on Liberty's head. The reverse shows some die cracks in the left wreath but not far enough along to be designated as the F-102a die state. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 blue label holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1875CC Seated 1875-CC
Above Bow
MS65
PCGS
45211121

Gem $3950 Beautiifully Original. Attractively Toned. Popular CC Dime. Decently well struck Carson City dime of the more common Above Bow variety. The bluish toning on both sides enhances the eye appeal. There are a few miniscule marks on both sides that makes MS65 the lowest possible grade.
Seated 10C 1876 Seated 1876
PF64
CACG
683040102

Choice $925 Nice Mirrors. This near gem has excellent mirrors under bluish grey toning with rose highlights.
Seated 10C 1876CC Seated 1876-CC
MS61
CACG
94072028
F-129
Choice $800 Well Struck and Original. This is an original and well struck example of the F-129 with doubling seen on the E in ONE on the reverse. Surfaces are attractively smooth for the grade. Light traces of rub on the obverse is the reason for the rather conservative grade from CACG.
Seated 10C 1876CC Seated 1876-CC
Type 2 Rev
EF45
PCGS
83650078
F-101
Choice HOLD
$950
Type 2 Reverse, CACd Choice Original, Top 100 Variety. This is the third time this 1876-CC Type 2 reverse example is back on the GFRC price list. This time it comes with a CAC sticker. This coin is slate blue-grey with good eye appeal. This is a scarce and important Top 100 Variety. The PCGS Pop is 2 in 45 with 4 higher. The CAC stickered pop is 3, one in 15, this 45 and one higher in 50. There are two CACG coins in 20 and 25. If you are building a seated dime variety set or want to add a variety coin to your seated dime set, this is your coin.
Seated 10C 1877S Seated 1877-S
MS65
PCGS
55457544
F-111
R5
Gem $5750 New August 15! Magnificent Gem, Granular Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Rare Die Pairing. Ex. Evergreen Collection. GFRC is thrilled to be offering one of the finest 1877-S dimes extant along with being a rare R5 die pairing per my research as published in the Liberty Seated Dime die variety online reference. This is a magnificent gem with granular frosted luster and vibrant cartwheels. A speckled natural gray patina overlays the obverse while the reverse is a lighter uniform gray with gold and rose shades appearing under angled lighting. The surfaces are meticulously preserved too! Now let's move on to the importance of this die pairing in terms of rarity. The F-111 variety is the last of the three different reverse die pairings (F-109, F-110, F-111) with Obverse 7. Reverse C, which was previously paired with the F-103 obverse, shows die wear and erosion at the denticles. There is considerable weakness in the lower left ribbon end and wreath leaves. The reverse die may have been polished after the F-103 die pairing. This is only the fourth F-111 example handled by GFRC with the next finest being a PCGS MS62 CAC example sold during May 2018. Clearly, the finest known F-111 extant. CAC has approved only 33 examples in all grades with five finer. The estimate CAC market value is currently $4900 which recognizes the 1877-S date rarity in full gem. An important offering that belongs in one of the finest Seated dime collections being assembled. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1880 Seated 1880
MS66+
PCGS
25004984
F-102a
Gem $2650 New September 28! Low Mintage Circulation Strike, Partially Mirrored, Gem Original. Ex. Evergreen and Sheffield Collections. Three die pairs were employed for the 1880 Philadelphia dime issue, only two of which were used for circulation strikes. The F-102 die pairing can be located as a proof strike followed by the F-102a circulation strike as is the case with this offering. Since the dies were reused, it is not uncommon to see partially mirrored fields for well preserved F-102a survivors. This example radiates mirrored reflectance that is not impeded by the orange-rose patination. Accurately graded with unquestionably originality. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (20013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1880 Seated 1880
MS64
PCGS
36155036

Choice $900 New August 18! Reduced Price - Mintage of 36,000. Gorgeous Reverse. The mintage for 1879-1881 Philadelphia dimes were a small fraction from the high mintage 1872-1878 issues. This coin is original and nicely struck. The coin is clean for an MS64. Both sides have slate grey toning with the obverse having darker toning surrounding the date and United States of America. The reverse is lighter and would grade at least MS65 by itself.
Seated 10C 1881 Seated 1881
PF64CAM
PCGS
64627138

Gem $1500 New August 19! Gorgeous Color on Heavily Frosted Devices. Simply beautiful! The obverse is gorgeously toned in vibrant blue, magenta, and orange colors. A hairline or two on the right obverse field can be seen, but doesn't distract from the incredible eye appeal of this coin. The devices on the reverse appear to be a deep cameo. While not a super high grade, this looks better than many proofs graded much higher.
Seated 10C 1881 Seated 1881
MS63
PCGS OGH
8094442

Choice HOLD
$1725
New September 29! OGH. Well Struck with Clean Surfaces. Just 24,000 were minted. Interestingly, there are only 28 CAC examples of this date in all grades compared to 98 for the 1879 dime where only 14,000 were minted. Well struck and brilliant white, there are some small marks on the obverse fields, but MS63 in this OGH holder is a bit conservative. The reverse is highly lustrous and would grade MS64 on its own. In a PCGS Gen. 3.1 (1993-1998) OGH holder.
Seated 10C 1883 Seated 1883
MS66
PCGS
13498669

Choice HOLD
$1250
New September 10! Lustrous, Nicely Struck with Attractive Obverse Rim Toning. Ex. Evergreen Collection. The attractive obverse rim toning of mostly orange with bluish and magenta hints with a lustrous center catches the eyes immediately. The obverse is well struck. Small obverse ticks can be seen with a loupe. The reverse is original white and mark free with a touch of weakness on the top left portion of the wreath. In a PCGS Gen. 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
Seated 10C 1886S Seated 1886-S
MS62
NGC
1647262012
F-101
Choice HOLD
$1400
New October 1! Better Late San Francisco Date, Golden Coloring, Frosty Cartwheel Luster, City by The Bay Collection.. The 1886-S F-101 die pair is much more frequently encountered than the rare F-102. On the F-101 obverse, the date slopes down while the 8 digit is well centered under the pendant. Both the obverse and reverse dies are free of defects. This date is notably scarce in the lower Mint State grades with only 4 certified by PCGS at MS62 followed by 7 in MS63. The CAC population is surprisingly low with only 20 approved in all grades. Surfaces offer frosty luster and golden shades when examined under a bright light. The strike is crisp and completely executed, atypical for the With Legend hub design. Housed in NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4697.
Seated 10C 1887 Seated 1887
MS66+
PCGS
50140255
F-108
Choice $1700 New September 28! Well Struck, Lustrous and Original. Ex. Evergreen Collection. The PCGS Population is 8 with just 9 higher. Well struck with coppery toning on lustrous original surfaces. Accurately graded with some small marks seen on both sides.
Seated 10C 1887S Seated 1887-S
MS65
PCGS
21552355
F-108
Gem $1250 New August 16! Gem Original. Ex. Evergreen and Gerry Fortin Collections. An impeccable strike is promptly noted with completely defined device elements on this brilliantly frosted specimen. The cartwheel action is intriguing while olive-green, orange-rose and hints of gold are quite attractive. Accurately graded given two micro-ticks in the right obverse field. The 1887-S issue is a slightly better date in lofty Mint State grades. F-108 with a high level date and weak base above the 887 digits. Worthy of an auction lot viewing effort as the luster is quite convincing. The overall CAC census reports 70 approved with twelve finer. Bowers & Merena June 2010 Baltimore Sale, Lot #1844. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4699.
Seated 10C 1888 Seated 1888
MS64
PCGS
40802656

Gem $695 Dual Sided Toning with Loads of Eye Appeal. Ex Seal Beach. Excellent eye appeal defines this coin. The obverse is mostly bluish yellow. The reverse is exceptional with orange magenta color surrounding the bluish yellow center. The obverse head detail is somewhat weakly struck, but the reverse is well struck. There is a slight luster graze in the field above Miss Liberty's left facing shoulder.
Seated 10C 1888S Seated 1888-S
MS66
PCGS
39743083
Unlisted
Gem $6750 New August 22! Unlisted Die Pairing, Gem Original. Ex. Evergreen and Massachusetts Collections. Moderate, steely luster produces swirling cartwheels as this San Francisco piece is rotated under a light. Gray fields hide subtle maroon color in the protected areas of the obverse, while the rims are more intensely shaded with evergreen patina. The reverse reveals blue color behind the wreath, with subtle lilac hues evident at the center. Unlisted in the Fortin web-book, with a level date and thick mintmark that are consistent with Obverse 9 and Reverse D. Tied for finest known at CAC with seven other coins and a single CACG MS66+ finer. The CAC guide value is $6,750, not inexpensive, but still a reasonable value with no finer approved survivors known. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4701.
Seated 10C 1889 Seated 1889
Doubled Die Reverse
MS63
PCGS
21300803
F-122
Choice $775 New August 21! Doubled Die Reverse #3, Choice Original, Top 100 Varieties. Lustrous silver surfaces admit occasional shades of smoky gray patina in the protected areas, highlighted by hints of gold color here and there. Nicely struck, with a near full head and distinct detail in the left stalk. F-122, the doubled die reverse, most notably apparent at the upper left leaf, but additionally evident in (O)NE and elsewhere. The reverse die is shared with F-106, and this is a visually compelling variety, #89 on the Top-100 Varieties list (http://www.seateddimevarieties.com/major_100_table2.htm). CAC has certified 96 pieces overall. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4702.
Seated 10C 1889S Seated 1889-S
MS64
PCGS
43181572
F-108
Choice $1600 New August 17! Steely Reflectivity, Near-Gem Original. Ex. Evergreen and Newtown Collections. Steely surfaces reveal light, crusty gray patina with a few deeper shades at the rim, while the reverse reveals additional, even rose color. A few marks are hidden within the figure of Liberty. F-108, with an even date and the mintmark centered under the bow knot. The CAC pop report notes seven pieces in MS64, seven coins in MS65, and two examples in MS66. The CAC price guide value is $1,400. This is a pleasing example for the money, attractively toned and reasonably close to the top of the census. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval. This lot brings the well known Newtown Collection pedigree and returns to the GFRC price list after a buyback.
Seated 10C 1890 Seated 1890
MS66+
PCGS
81381305

Choice $1650 New September 28! Near Gem. Well Struck with Original Attractive Toning. Ex. Evergreen Collection. The PCGS Population is 5 with just 8 higher. Well Struck with attractive toning on original surfaces. The obverse is toned reddish orange with magenta. The reverse is bluish grey and is at least an MS67 on its own. Pedigreed in a D. L. Hansen label.
Seated 10C 1891 Seated 1891
MS65
PCGS
14166045

Choice $875 Strictly Original. CAC MS65 Quality. This is a no question original coin with no mentionable marks. Swirling a coin under a light, the reverse displays pizazz with rainbow colors and well struck details. In a PCGS Gen. 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
Seated 10C 1891S Seated 1891-S
MS66
PCGS
5801959
F-116
Gem $2750 New September 28! Gem Original. Ex. Evergreen, Gerry Fortin and Darrell Low Collections. Spinning cartwheels and blazing frosted luster are consistent with a higher grade rendering this old-time acquisition as an upgrade candidate. An acutely hammered strike leads to meticulously detailed motifs with subtle die polished lines across Liberty's breasts. Light gold in concentrated at the obverse rims and throughout the reverse. In hand inspection is suggested as this little lady provides exceptional eye appeal. F-116 with high level date and polished reverse die along with yet another plate coins within the Liberty Seated Dime online die variety reference. The CAC census notes 64 in all grades with twelve MS66 and five finer. Acquired by Gerry Fortin in November 2005 via Darrell Low. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder with CAC Approval. PCGS #4708.
Barber 10C 1901O Barber 1901-O
MS66+
PCGS
6666231

Gem $7250 Price Reduction - Exceptional Gem. An exceptional gem from the incredible Simpson Collection and among the finest known examples. PCGS has graded 2 in this grade with only a single 67 finer while CAC has beened 3 in 66 (not sure how many of these had a plus) plus one in 67. A must have for a date collector of the finest Barber dimes or for the New Orleans specialist.
Barber 10C 1910 Barber 1910
MS66+
PCGS
56533849

Gem $1800 New October 11! Gorgeous Subtle Colors. Light grey but as the coin is viewed under a light, hints of various pastle colors become evident. Beautiful russel and mauve toning around the lower reverse. Excellent luster. The coin would grade higher if not for a few small marks on the neck.
Barber 10C 1911 Barber 1911
MS67
PCGS
53615223

Choice $3500 Attractive Dual Sided Toning. This coin has wonderful dual sided toning. Miss Liberty has an almost cameo look as she stands out from the rainbow toned fields around her. There are two small light ticks that can be seen on Miss Liberty's cheek under magnification. The well struck reverse has vibrant orange and olive green toning and completely mark free.
Mercury 10C 1929 Mercury 1929
MS65FB
PCGS
47304149

Gem $495 New September 10! Lustrous Well Struck Gem. An exceptional strike and blazing luster are the hallmarks of this gem Mercury dime. Only a few unobtrusive marks are noted.
Mercury 10C 1936S Mercury 1936-S
MS67FB
PCGS
25628662

Gem $895 Undipped and Flashy. Excellent luster and flash on this premium gem. Unlike most white mercs, this one has undipped surfaces with nice frost and few marks. Well struck too.
Mercury 10C 1937S Mercury 1937-S
MS66FB
PCGS
37230512

Gem $595 New September 28! Exceptional Eye Appeal and Well Struck. This is a coin where the picture is worth a thousand words. This is a beautiful coin with exceptional rainbow rim toning. Well struck, lustrous, and original. With a loupe and tilting the coin a certain way, there is a light luster graze on the cheek. It will be tough to find a more eye appealing example.
Mercury 10C 1941S Mercury 1941-S
MS67FB
PCGS
15407349

Gem HOLD
$325
New September 28! Superb Gem; Excellent Strike. Blast white with blazing luster and a full strike.
Roosevelt 10C 1946S Roosevelt 1946-S
MS68FB
CACG
958267761

Gem $1795 Single Finest CAC Endorsed Example. This is the only example of this issue graded MS68FB by CACG and is drop dead gorgeous. Fantastic target toned color on both sides beneath great luster. This has legitimate claims to be the finest known example of this issue.
20 Cents
There are currently no coins for sale fitting this criteria.
25 Cents
Seated 25C 1840 Seated 1840
Drapery
EF40
PCGS
80668428

Choice HOLD
$695
Surprisingly Tough to Find with CAC. The 1840 with drapery quarter is difficult to find nice with just 24 examples endorsed by CAC which compares to a number of the more recognized scarcer dates. Strictly original with light grey surfaces. There are some small scattered marks on the obverse that are well toned over. This coin was traded for another coin at Batlimore and is now available to our Seated quarter collectors looking to add this difficult piece.
Seated 25C 1843O Seated 1843-O
Large O
F15
PCGS
29806057
Briggs 3-F
Choice $1500 Large O, Choice Original, Scarce Die Variety, Crusty Gray Patina, Accurately Graded. Listed separately by Briggs as 3-F and the lone 1843 reverse die with a Large O mintmark. Later captured by the Cherrypickers Guide and listed as FS-501. Always found in lower circulated grades with the finest PCGS holdered being an AU53 example. This Fine 15 example is noteworthy for its strict originality and choice surfaces. Crusty gray patina covers both sides. CAC approval is absolutely warranted due to originality and accurate grading. Overall, an essentially unimprovable example for the collector wishing to fill the #5 spot, in a Top 25 Varieties set. Housed in a PCGS Gen 5.0 Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval. The PCGS label reads, "Large O FS-501 (FS-001.5)".
Seated 25C 1844 Seated 1844
MS62
CACG
974283076

Choice $2250 New September 14! Nicely Struck, Original Surfaces.. Strictly original medium grey surfaces are nicely struck. There are some obverse marks that warrant the MS62 grade. The reverse is nicer and grades MS63.
Seated 25C 1847 Seated 1847
AU55
CACG
82896440

Choice $975 Attractive Patches of Color on Obverse. Attractive patches of blue, magenta, and orange toning adds to the eye appeal of this original coin. The rims on both sides are nicely struck, but the centers are more weakly struck. On the reverse, the left facing wing, shield and the arrow nock are weakly struck. Some marks and handling lines can be seen, but none are overly distracting. In a CACG Witter Brick holder.
Seated 25C 1847O Seated 1847-O
VF30
PCGS
50571189

Choice HOLD
$950
Better O-mint Quarter. Original Medium Grey. Just 34 coins endorsed by CAC in all grades. This is an original medium grey better date O-mint quarter. Some thin scratches are seen on the obverse right field, to the left of star 7, and above the Phrygian Cap. There is also a rim ding near star 11. The reverse surfaces are decently smooth with dirt embedded withn the eagle and on the first S in STATES. There is an interesting die crack on the reverse at ES OF.
Seated 25C 1849 Seated 1849
MS64
PCGS
3456067

Choice $6500 New September 14! Excellent Luster, Well Struck, Original.. Beautiful original luster on this well struck mostly white coin. The obverse is a high end MS64 while the reverse Is an MS64 due to some marks in the field to the left of the eagle's beak. In a PCGS Gen. 4.0 (1998-2002) holder.
Seated 25C 1850O Seated 1850-O
MS63
PCGS
14526833

Choice $6500 New September 14! Well Struck Coin, Better Date.. 1850-O quarters are difficult to find in Uncirculated condition with a CAC endorsement. There are two CAC coins in MS63 with just 6 higher which likely includes some resubmissions. This coin is well struck with lovely bluish color on the rims and magenta centers most prominent on the reverse. There are some marks on the right obverse field that define the grade. Housed in a PCGS Gen. 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
Seated 25C 1851O Seated 1851-O
VF20
PCGS
19175171

Choice $1800 New September 14! Just 23 Endorsed by CAC at Any Grade. Original and Nicely Struck.. Ex. New Orleans Collection. 1851-O quarters are known to be poorly struck, but this coin is a happy exception. There are only 23 examples endorsed by CAC at any grade. Original light grey surfaces show even wear. Attesting to the originality, embedded dirt can be seen around all the devices. Some abrasions and marks can be seen on both sides.
Seated 25C 1852 Seated 1852
MS62
PCGS
44924563

Choice $5000 New September 14! Well Struck on Strictly Original Surfaces.. With the decrease in silver content on coins in 1853, older coins were removed from circulation and melted which impacted 1850-1852 dated coins the most. There are 28 coins endorsed by CAC in all grades with 2 in MS62 and 9 higher. This is a well struck strictly original example. From an arm's length, this looks like coin that should grade higher. Small horizontal handling lines on the right obverse field and a mark on Miss Liberty's right facing arm makes MS62 an appropriate grade.
Seated 25C 1856S Seated 1856-S
EF45
PCGS OGH
96365971

Choice $6950 New September 14! OGH, Highly Lustrous, Good Strike.. This coin is arguably an AU coin based on excellent luster and good detail. The obverse is well struck with some small marks on the right obverse field towards the left side. Light roller marks can be seen across Miss Liberty's chest. The reverse is quite smooth with just a hint of weakness in the eagle's left facing leg. Housed in a PCGS Gen. 3.0 (1990-1993) OGH holder.
Seated 25C 1857O Seated 1857-O
MS63
PCGS
21308588

Choice $5250 New September 14! Excellent Luster and Decently Struck.. The luster is excellent on this flashy coin. The rims are attractively toned blue and copper on both sides. The obverse is well struck with the reverse displaying some weakness on the left facing leg, arrow nock, and the shield. There are some small marks and handling lines that makes the MS63 grade accurate. In a PCGS Gen. 4.1 (2002-2004) holder.
Seated 25C 1859S Seated 1859-S
VF30
PCGS
25592796

Choice $4200 New September 14! Pop 2 at CAC with just 4 Higher. Good Originality, Medium Grey Surfaces.. Just 80,000 1859-S quarters were minted. Only 23 coins endorsed by CAC in all grades. There are 2 VF30 CAC coins with just 4 higher. Some handling lines and marks seen on both sides of this medium grey coin. On the obverse, there is a small pinscratch to the left of the Phrygian cap towards the rim. In a PCGS Gen. 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
Seated 25C 1859S Seated 1859-S
VF25
PCGS
11776686

Choice $4250 Just 23 CAC Endorsed Examples in All Grades. This coin is very difficult to price due to the recent sale of a gem PCGS-XF40 CAC for $18,000, more than triple the CPG retail price. Decently struck with the large S mintmark of this era. There are some scattered abrasions and light handling lines on the obverse. The reverse has smooth surfaces. There are only 23 CAC endorsed examples in all grades.
Seated 25C 1859S Seated 1859-S
F15
PCGS
34428066
Briggs 1-A
Choice $1650 Rare San Francisco Date, Smooth Surfaces, Choice Original. Ex. Tenafly Collection. The 1859-S is a well-known low mintage date in the quarter series that becomes non-existent at the Mint State level. This coin is exceptional for the grade with remarkably smooth surfaces for a F-15 example. Pleasing, medium gray patina covers both sides with light crust around the left stars. The CAC population report indicates 21 approved pieces in all grades with an incremental three CACG holdered. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. A collector of circulated quarters would be hard pressed to find a more attractive example in the F/VF band, as Briggs notes most pieces come with problems. PCGS #5450.
Seated 25C 1860S Seated 1860-S
F12
PCGS
18254441

Choice $5200 Better Date. Tough Coin in F12 CAC or Higher. From a sheer number of survivors, there are other S-mint Seated quarters that are tougher to find, but the majority of 1860-S qiarters that exist either have problems or are VG or lower. This original coin shows a full LIBERTY.There are some handling lines with a minimal number of marks. The reverse does have a characteristic strike weakness from 6 o'clock to 9 o'clock, but the center of the reverse grades at least F12.
Seated 25C 1861 Seated 1861
AU58
PCGS
3658092

Gem HOLD
$1500
New October 1! Sensational Concentric Rainbow Toning!. There are few coins that we would consider unbelievable looking for the grade. This is one of them. Both sides with concentric rainbow colors brings out of this world eye appeal for this Civil War coin. Well struck and lustrous with the slightest of wear. Small marks are hidden beneath the vibrant toning. Please offer coins like this to us. The lines and haze on the obverse are from the holder and not on the coin. In a PCGS Gen. 4.0 (1998-2002) holder.
Seated 25C 1862 Seated 1862
MS64
PCGS OGH
3103671

Choice HOLD
$1750
New September 14! OGH. Fully Struck with Excellent Luster.. Fully struck and just about a brilliant white coin with excellent luster. There are no handling lines seen, but there are some marks on both sides. In a PCGS Gen. 3.1 (1993-1998) OGH holder.
Seated 25C 1862S Seated 1862-S
AU53
PCGS
10009383

Choice HOLD
$4500
New September 14! Well Struck. Difficult to find in AU CAC.. Just 67,000 minted of this in demand Civil War date. This is just one of three coins in AU with a CAC endorsement. This AU53 CAC coin with two in AU58 CAC and seven Uncirculated CAC coins. This coin is well struck on light grey surfaces. The obverse displays some small marks and vertical handling lines on the right obverse field. The reverse by itself is gem quality. In a PCGS Gen. 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
Seated 25C 1863 Seated 1863
MS64+
PCGS
51663938

Gem HOLD
$5750
New October 2! Easily a Gem with Gorgeous Toning.. Ex. D. Low. This is my old set coin (DL) that I sold some time ago after keeping it for more than 10 years and has now been consigned to GFRC. This Civil War coin is fully struck on both sides. The obverse has a few more small marks to warrant the grade. The reverse is smooth and is easily an MS65 or better. At this grade level or lower, this is the best looking 1863 quarter I have ever seen.
Seated 25C 1864 Seated 1864
MS62
PCGS
27741440

Choice $3000 No Noticeable Marks. CAC has endorsed just this coin at this grade and 15 coins at MS64 or higher. A nicely struck Civil War era coin with no noticeable marks. Toning is mostly brownish with traces of purple on the reverse near QUAR. DOL. The luster on the reverse is excellent, but muted on the obverse which probably kept this coin from a higher grade. Some die clashing can be seen on the reverse.
Seated 25C 1866 Seated 1866
MS62
PCGS
8838481

Choice $5000 New September 14! Attractive Toning, Fully Struck Obverse, Scarce Date.. Just 16,800 minted of this first year With Motto design. After looking at many 1866 quarters over the last 30 years, this is among the very best struck ones seen by the writer (DL). The obverse is fully struck with the reverse showing the usual weakness to the left side of the shield but is bolder than usual for the date. The toning is attractive with the obverse displaying hues of blue, deep magenta, and yellowish orange. The reverse is light blue and magenta. There are few marks or handling lines. The reverse grades at least MS64. In a PCGS Gen. 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
Seated 25C 1867S Seated 1867-S
VF30
PCGS
16126775

Choice $3700 New September 14! Strictly Original, Tough with CAC Endorsement.. Only 48,000 minted. Just 15 examples have been endorsed by CAC at any grade making it one of the most difficult Seated quarters to find with CAC. This coin is strictly original. With a loupe, there are some very thin scratches on the lower half of Miss Liberty. The reverse is gem quality.
Seated 25C 1870CC Seated 1870-CC
VG10
PCGS
13249017

Choice HOLD
$23000
New September 12! One of the Big Three Key Date CCs, Great Detail for a VG Coin.. The 1870-CC is one of the big three key date CC Seated Quarters, along with the 1871-CC and 1873-CC Arrows.. Just 8,340 coins were issued of which less than 100 still exist. The CAC Population Report shows 3 in VG10 with 10 higher. The full LIBERTY on the shield is visible on this light grey example which in the past would make the coin grade Fine-12. There are some old scratches seen on both sides. With a loupe, there is a difficult to see very thin straight scratch from Miss Liberty's head running diagonally to her left facing breast and from her left facing hand to the left side of the rock. Housed In a PCGS Gen. 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
Seated 25C 1878 Seated 1878
MS63
PCGS
58338354

Choice HOLD
$975
New October 1! Tough to Find Endorsed by CAC. Original with Subtle Toning and Clean Surfaces. Just 29 endorsed by CAC in all grades with this being the only MS63 with 8 higher. This is suprisingly difficult to find endorsed by CAC despite a sizable mintage. Tthe attractive subtle bluish and yellow green toning contains unusually few marks for an MS63. The obverse stars are mostly weakly struck.
Seated 25C 1878CC Seated 1878-CC
MS64
PCGS
12737757

Choice HOLD
$2800
New September 14! Highly Lustrous and Well Struck.. This better date of this Carson City issue is well struck and has excellent luster. There is some light copper toning towards the rims. During striking of the reverse, there is a curved mark that is not sharp and not continuous from the first S in STATES to the D in GOD. Other than that, there are few marks of note. In a PCGS Gen. 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
Seated 25C 1878S Seated 1878-S
MS64
PCGS
44910326

Choice $9750 New September 14! Well Struck with Few Marks.. Mintage of 140,000. Diffiuclt date to find endorsed by CAC with only 22 at any grade. There are 3 at MS64 wth 5 higher at CAC. Well struck with few marks on either side. The obverse has subtle light blue and magenta toning. The reverse has olive green toning.
Seated 25C 1879 Seated 1879
MS64
PCGS
6693855

Choice $2100 New September 14! Near Gem. Superb Luster on Original Surfaces.. Low mintage of 13,600. The superb swirling luster stands out on this well struck original coin with prooflike characteriestics. Some bluish and coppery rim toning enhances the beauty of this coin. Small obverse marks probably keep it below MS65, but it is close. The reverse grades at least MS66. In a PCGS Gen. 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
Seated 25C 1891 Seated 1891
AU53
PCGS
11199954

Gem HOLD
$575
New September 28! Exceptional Toning for this Last Year of Type. Wondrous dual sided toning of this last year of type issue. Miss Liberty is magenta with the fields surrounding her a vibrant blue with some reddish orange toning towards the rims. A few obverse marks are seen beneath the toning. In a PCGS Gen. 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
Barber 25C 1896S Barber 1896-S
G4
CACG
175995980

Choice $975 One of the "Big 3" Barber Quarters. The 1896-S, 1901-S, and 1913-S quarters stand as the key dates of the series. While heavily circulated, this coin is quite a bit nicer than the typical low grade 1896-S quarter and would fill a big hole in building a set.
Barber 25C 1900S Barber 1900-S
AU58
PCGS
38189071

Choice $895 Well Struck with Good Luster. This turn of the century branch mint coin is well struck and posseses good underlying luster on original surfaces for this ever popular AU58 grade. The surfaces are bathed in copper toning with deeper copper highlights in some areas around the rim. Under a loupe, light handling lines can be seen on Miss Liberty's cheek
Barber 25C 1902 Barber 1902
AU55
PCGS
28008041

Gem HOLD
$330
Nice Luster. Gorgeous Reverse Toning. A common date with an uncommon look. Lustrous surfaces bathes the coin. The obverse displays light blue, magenta, and copper toning towards the rims. There is a thin scratch below Miss Liberty's eye and some marks near star 11. The reverse toning is simply marvelous with blue, magenta, green, and yellow seen in the fields.
Barber 25C 1911D Barber 1911-D
AU55
PCGS
18521530

Choice $1200 Better Date. Original and Lustrous. Barber quarter specialists know that the 11-D is a much better date in the series. This one is brilliant white with darker speckles more apparent on the reverse. It is smooth with no mentionable marks.The coin is decently struck with just star 3 being weaker. This is a tough coin to find with CAC endorsement with two in AU55, three in AU58 and just 6 Uncs.
Barber 25C 1914S Barber 1914-S
VG10
CACG
969736599

Choice $295 264,000 Mintage. Better Date. For a well circulated coin, it still shows 4 1/2 letters of LIBERTY. This light grey coin has an original skin and has few imperfections giving it great eye appeal.
Standing Liberty 25C 1917 Standing Liberty 1917
Type 1
MS66FH
PCGS
43603503

Gem $2950 New August 16! Type 1, Full Head, Unquestionable Gem, Granular Frosted Luster, CAC Approval. Ex. Evergreen. How we enjoy handling high end Standing Liberty quarters when unquestionably original as this 1917 Type 1 MS66 Full Head specimen. The micro-granular frosted luster glows with angled lighting. The creamy light golden-gray patina also screams originality along with mottled toning at the peripheries. Surfaces are absolutely pristine under 10x. Strike is hammered with bold head and shield rivets fully defined. If searching for that ultimate 1917 Type 1 piece for a type set, a close inspection might be warranted. We just don't often see this marvelous preservation state on silver coinage. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 holder with CAC approval.
Standing Liberty 25C 1921 Standing Liberty 1921
MS64
PCGS
33926365

Choice $3300 Original White of this Better Date. This is an original white example of this better date Standing Liberty Quarter. The strike is decent and the fields are smooth. There is an interesting die crack that traverses the top of the date. On the reverse, there is a scratch on the left facing wing that looks to be the only reason why it is not in an MS65 holder.
Standing Liberty 25C 1921 Standing Liberty 1921
EF40
PCGS
56296056

Choice $1095 New September 29! Original and Choice. A smooth, perfectly original example of this key date. Slate grey with golden highlights. The date is well struck. A great, high quality example for a circulated set.
50 Cents
Capped Bust 50C 1806 Capped Bust 1806
Pointed 6, Stem
VG10
PCGS
19225725
O-118b
R4
Choice HOLD
$850
Original and Smooth; Cool Die Cracks. A cool die variety with die cracks from rim to claw, through TED and from rim through the O in OF into the stars. The coin looks just how a totally original 1806 half should look with even grey surfaces. The surfaces and the rims are very clean and the detail is good for a F12, except for the eagle's left facing wing which is weak due to striking weakness caused by the die breaks.
Capped Bust 50C 1811/10 Capped Bust 1811/10
MS62
PCGS
16110402
O-101
Gem $9500 New August 20! 1811/10 Overdate, Scare in Mint State, Superb Bright Light Colors. The obverse tan shades and reverse greens give way to center rose and aquamarine surrounded by peripheral gold once activated. Fields are steely with ample luster for spinning cartwheels. The toning may appear thick from the images, but actually is quite transparent. This piece warrants a Gem quality rating and is fairly priced for the premium nature. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. The label documents the Witham pedigree.
Capped Bust 50C 1812 Capped Bust 1812
MS62+
PCGS
43331784
O-107
Choice $3950 New August 20! Granular Frosted Luster, Pristine Surfaces, Heavy Die Clashing, Center Dot. Granular frosted luster and light gray patina are promptly noted when inspecting this choice 1812 O-107 half. It is difficult to imagine how such an early piece of Americana can be so well preserved. Surfaces are pristine with any abnormalities being die clashing. A small obverse center dot is evident along with die crack from milling up through the lower bust. Another GFRC new offering that is certain to please the knowledgeable numismatist. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval.
Capped Bust 50C 1813 Capped Bust 1813
EF45
PCGS
37026697

Choice $925 Super Original. Both sides have grey toning with original luster peaking out at the stars and letters. Weakly struck at the lower reverse and upper part of the obverse.
Capped Bust 50C 1814 Capped Bust 1814
AU58
PCGS
11458785
O-103
Gem $2950 New August 20! Gem Original. Ex. Evergreen. A very attractive and completely original looking Capped Bust half dollar. Nice mint luster remains on both sides. The centers are largely deep silver grey, with delightful sunset hues around the rims. Nicely struck from dies that clashed multiple times, leaving an interesting array of clashmarks on both sides of the struck coin. A heavy die defect connects the left wing of the eagle to the scroll above, and makes this common variety easy to quickly identify.
Capped Bust 50C 1814 Capped Bust 1814
AU50
PCGS
83089023
O-107a
R5
Choice $1595 R5 Die State: Original Grey Toning. This slate grey PCGS AU 50 CAC Bust half is the late die state of O-107 with a die break on the tip of Liberty's nose. It is considered R-5 and is an important and interesting coin for Bust half variety collectors. In AU 50 CAC, we believe this approaches the condition census. This is a fully original coin with grey toning. A moderate sratch on the cheek is noted.
Capped Bust 50C 1817 Capped Bust 1817
AU55
PCGS
29409164
O-103b
R5
Choice $3750 New October 8! O-103b, R5. Original with Great Luster. Silver centers with light colorful toning at the edges. Full cartwheel luster makes this R5 variety coin pop. CPG Bid is $3,600 and CPG Retail is $4,500 for this die state.
Capped Bust 50C 1819 Capped Bust 1819
AU50
PCGS
27927377
O-114
Choice $1250 New September 28! Strictly Original with a Gem Reverse. Unquestionably original dove grey surfaces show a bare minimum of marks. Good detail in Miss Liberty's hair and the eagle's feathers. The reverse has few marks and is gem quality.
Capped Bust 50C 1823 Capped Bust 1823
Patched 3
MS62
PCGS
39322807
O-101a
Choice $7950 New August 21! Patched 3, Exceptional Eye Appeal, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Very Scarce CAC Approved. A luscious 1823 O-101a Patched 3 offering that would be a highlight in an advanced Capped Bust half dollar collection. Beautifully preserved with a stunning presentation of brilliant frosted luster and surrounding copper-gold and aquamarine-blue peripheral toning at the rims. A few luster breaks in the left obverse field account for the technical grade. Eye appeal however, is that of a higher grade. Mint worker efforts to "patch" the center of the digit is easily seen under 10x. This is a low CAC population variety that is always popular. Only three have been approved at this grade level with six finer. The pricing premiums grow much more substantial at Choice Mint State. I like this piece so much that a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation is warranted as this is such a pretty example. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 holder with CAC approval.
Capped Bust 50C 1825 Capped Bust 1825
VF25
NGC
3606252006
O-114
Choice $325 New September 25! Choice Original. Ex. Sooner Collection. Charcoal grey toning with rust-gold around the devices. All design elements are well detailed despite the wear except the stars. An original and attractive coin.
Capped Bust 50C 1826 Capped Bust 1826
MS62+
PCGS
29295317
O-112
Gem $3950 New August 23! Exceptional Gem, Sparkling Radiance, A Truly Differentiated Example. What differentiates this exceptional gem 1826 O-112 specimen from nearly all other Capped Bust halves seen is the sparkling radiance that is 100% consistent on both sides. Under a bright light, this piece is jaw dropping with awesome peripheral gold luster and dancing cartwheels. GFRC images capture in the in-hand appearance while a check of the PCGS TrueView will provide a hint of the radiance. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval and Link pedigree on the label. Immediately sold upon being posted in the Daily Blog.
Capped Bust 50C 1826 Capped Bust 1826
AU55
PCGS
16656644
O-116a
Choice $795 Strictly Original with Few Marks. This is a strictly original 200 year old light grey Bust half with few marks of any note. The reverse has some darker patches which embodies the originality.
Capped Bust 50C 1829 Capped Bust 1829
AU58
PCGS
21726649
O-113a
Choice $1600 New August 16! Steely Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Completed Strike, Choice Surfaces. Ex. Evergreen and Twin Lakes Collections. Capped Bust half dollar fans should pay close attention to this 1829 O-113a specimen. Unquestionably choice with smooth steely fields and unabraded surfaces. Luster is the typical steely-frosted texture often see on early halves at this grade level. Light copper-gold toning is fairly consistent on both sides and does not impede the underlying luster during bright light inspection. The O-113a die state can be attributed by the last A in STATES being filled. Yet another excellent Twin Lakes release. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.3 (2004) holder with CAC approval.
Capped Bust 50C 1829 Capped Bust 1829
Small Letters
AU55
CACG
916384004
O-119
Choice $850 Strictly Original. Accurately Graded. Strictly original with light grey surfaces. There is a thin ring of orange toning along the obverse rims that enhances the eye appeal. Some old thin lines can be seen on the obverse, but are not too distracting. The reverse is decently struck with smooth surfaces and is gem quality on its own.
Capped Bust 50C 1830 Capped Bust 1830
Small 0
AU58
PCGS
44225561
O-115
Choice $1350 New August 17! Small 0, Super Eye Appeal, Briliant Frosted Luster, Near-Gem. Ex. Evergreen and Twin Lakes Collections. This is a near-gem 1830 O-115 Capped Bust half release that has excellent eye appeal. Inspection under angled lighting will immediately convince collectors to take this one home as the frosted luster is quite intense and eye catching. Undisturbed granular mint frost is readily seen with a 10x. Speckled gray-ebony toning nicely frames the brilliant centers. Reverse strike is deeply impressed while the obverse clasp is weakly defined. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CA approval.
Capped Bust 50C 1831 Capped Bust 1831
MS64
PCGS
36782850
O-106
Choice $4950 New August 19! Well Struck, Original Surfaces. Ex. Evergreen. Pale grey toning over frosty original surfaces. Very well struck with hardly a trace of rub. The surfaces are smooth for the grade.
Capped Bust 50C 1834 Capped Bust 1834
Sm Date, Sm Ltrs
AU53
PCGS
32708883

Choice $850 Pretty Dual Sided Toning. This is a well struck lustrous Bust half dollar with wonderful dual sided toning. The reverse is slightly rotated. Beneath the color, there are some light lines on the left obverse field emanating near Miss Liberty's chin. The eye appeal will not disappoint.
Capped Bust 50C 1835 Capped Bust 1835
AU58
PCGS
11365973
O-101
Choice HOLD
$1175
New August 15! Choice Original. Ex. Evergreen and Twin Lakes Collections. Medium skin covers both sides, revealing silver and smoky gray patina, while the high points of Liberty exhibit deeper slate color. A few crusty bits reside here and there, most notably in the reverse shield. Hairline-free surfaces are clearly original, and the aesthetic appeal is wholesome. O-101, with the upper lip thick, and the 5 (in 50 C.) punched at a left slant. CAC reports 262 pieces in all grades combined, 51 examples in AU58, and 53 coins in Mint State. The CAC price guide assigns a value of $870. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6168
Capped Bust 50C 1835 Capped Bust 1835
EF40
CACG
436746183

Choice $450 Colorful Toning. This near gem has light grey surfaces with copper centers and beautiful colorful toning at the peripheries. The usual conservative grading by CACG.
Capped Bust 50C 1839 Capped Bust 1839
Capped Bust
VF35
NGC
5743372010

Choice $395 New October 2! Beautifully Original. Ex. Sooner Collection. This common Capped Bust half is deeply toned in charcoal grey but is not dark. The surfaces come alive under a light. One old toned over mark in front of Miss Liberty's chin but other than that, the surfaces and rims are clean. Originality can be beautiful.
Seated 50C 1843 Seated 1843
AU55
PCGS
42662575
WB-18
Choice HOLD
$995
New October 2! Excellent Luster and Eye Appeal. Ex. Sooner Collection. Light grey with fantastic luster. Superb striking detail in Miss Liberty's head and the eagle's feathers and claws. Interesting die cracks on both sides. Scattered but unobtrusive marks and lines on each side.
Seated 50C 1848O Seated 1848-O
MS63
PCGS
25685037
WB-8
Gem HOLD
$3425
New September 25! Frosty Gem. Ex. Sooner Collection. A frosty gem with bright grey surfaces and nice peripheral color. The luster is bold, marks are few and minor and the eye appeal is excellent.
Seated 50C 1850 Seated 1850
MS65+
PCGS
50073544
WB-4
Gem $45000 Condition Census, Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Consignor Price Reduction - Production of silver coinage began falling in 1850, as increasing supplies of gold caused an imbalance in the valuation of silver. Congress corrected the problem only with the Coinage Act of 1853, leaving the Mint to coin a decreasing supply of silver bullion in the intervening years. This low-mintage piece exhibits liberal copper and aqua patina, and the overall eye appeal merits the GFRC Gem designation. Ample luster imparts slight reflectivity to the surfaces. Stars are sharp, while the left claws remain separated, if faintly so. WB-4, with a tine to the upper left of 1. CAC has approved 28 coins total, with a single coin in MS65 (the present coin) and only one piece finer, at MS67. The CAC price guide value is $36,000 (CAC does not price plus grades), while the PCGS value at the MS65+ level is $60,000. Ex. GFRC, August 2023, at $53,000. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6264.
Seated 50C 1856S Seated 1856-S
AU55
CACG
160250845

Choice $6500 One of the Top 5 CAC coins. A highly lustrous example with a giant S mintmark on the reverse. Light obverse handling lines can be seen. A low popultion CAC coin in choice AU grades. There is one stickered as a 55, this one as a CACG AU55 and only two sticked in 58. GFRC sold one of the AU58s in March 2021 for $14,999 and Heritage sold the other AU55 CAC coin for $7,800 in October 2023 making this coin an execellent value.
Seated 50C 1858 Seated 1858
MS65
NGC Fatty
150793001

Gem $6600 New September 29! Gem Original, Great Color. Iridescent grey with all sorts of colors present when viewed under a light. Very clean with smooth surfaces throughout. Also with strong striking details, this would make an excellent type coin. In an old NGC Gen. 4.0 (1989-1992) holder.
Seated 50C 1860S Seated 1860-S
AU50
CACG
827691386

Choice $1200 New September 14! Choice Original. Attractive iridescent grey toning covers well preserved surfaces. A bit of crust around the devices creates a cameo effect. No marks worth of mention and only a few scattered lines.
Seated 50C 1869 Seated 1869
MS61
PCGS
80467651

Choice $1350 Choice Original. Ex. Spring Branch, Oregon Beaver and Seal Beach Collections. Steely surfaces exhibit silver patina marked by deeper maroon color in the stars, while the reverse reveals russet shades within the legend. The reverse fields are more reflective, serving to create pleasing contrast with the frosty eagle. Most star centers are defined, while the eagle claws to the left join together. WB-3, with a high date sloping downward. CAC has stickered 45 pieces in all grades, with 14 coins finer. The CAC price guide value is $1,350. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 holder with CAC approval.
Seated 50C 1870 Seated 1870
MS64
PCGS
19264518
WB-7
Choice HOLD
$3950
Near Gem Original. Ex. Spring Branch and Newtown Collections. Rich color covers both sides of this middle-date Philadelphia piece. Deep tan and chestnut patina underlays both sides, with navy blue highlights present in the left stars and aqua hue evident in the legend and protected areas of the obverse. Stars points are distinct and claw joints are separated, if faintly so. CAC has stickered 38 pieces total, with three coins at MS64 and only five examples finer, all at MS65. The CAC guide value is $3,600 in MS64 and $10,500 in MS65, making this the highest CAC-approved example one can hope to attain without a major, five-figure investment. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 50C 1874 Seated 1874
Arrows
MS61
PCGS
31445631

Choice $1495 New October 1! Lustrous Type Coin with Decent Strike. Ex. Sooner Collection. Despite the lower Uncirculated grade, this has good eye appeal for this type coin with mostly brilliant white surfaces. There is a little rim toning seen on both sides that enhances the eye appeal. Small marks can be seen especially on the obverse, but the MS61 grade seems conservative. The reverse is at least MS62 on its own.
Seated 50C 1874CC Seated 1874-CC
MS63
PCGS
25399807
WB-3
Choice $37000 Near-Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Along with the 1870-CC and 1878-CC, the 1874-CC is one of the keys to Carson City half dollar set. Few pieces survived from the small mintage of 59,000 pieces and today examples in all grades are highly prized. This piece exhibits even, medium gray toning, with hints of gold, russet, and blue more evident as the coin is tilted under a light. Moderate cartwheel radiates from both sides, a touch more actively on the reverse. WB-3, with a die lump below the curl and a diagonal die line through (STAT)ES. The mintmark is small with close spacing and slopes upward. Well struck with star centers evident and typical softness in the left claws. CAC has approved 47 coins total, a single piece in MS63 (the present coin), two examples at MS64, and a single coin at MS65. PCGS reports three higher pieces in MS64, one coin in MS65 and one example in MS66. The CAC price guide value is $37,400 while PCGS is a tick higher at $37,500. The significance of this offering is hard to overstate, as Carson City pieces are among the most desirable issues in the Seated series. This piece combines the all-important CC mintmark with key date status and a strong technical grade. As if that were not enough, CAC endorses this example as premium for the grade. The new owner of this special coin will be exceptionally pleased. Ex. GFRC (August 2021), at $35,000, previously from the Milford Collection (Heritage 1/2011, lot 5565), realized $26,450. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6347.
Seated 50C 1875 Seated 1875
MS65
PCGS
19696072

Gem $4500 Gem Original. Ex. Spring Branch and Newtown Collections. Blue-green and russet patina fill the rims of the GFRC-rated Gem example, complemented by frosty luster, and the aesthetic appeal is strong. Protected areas exhibit similar aqua color, contrasting with silver centers. The stars are well-defined, while a couple of the claw knuckles blend together. CAC notes 95 stickered pieces total, 11 coins in MS65, and two examples finer, all at MS66. The CAC price guide value is $4,100 in MS65. Ex. Heritage (February 2019, lot 4048), at $3,360. Sold by GFRC for $3850 in May 2025.Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 50C 1876 Seated 1876
MS66
PCGS
44698854

Gem $5500 Gem Original. Ex. Spring Branch and Newtown Collections. Reflective surfaces host russet fields and electric blue patina at the rim, and the eye appeal is immediately apparent. Central devices are lighter, with the deepest shades at the rim, a favored scheme among aficionados of toned coins. Typically struck, with stars to the right softly impressed. The 1876 die varieties are not fully documented, but this example is distinctive, with a low date. CAC has stickered 79 examples in all grades, three coins in MS66, and a one MS67 finer. The CAC price guide value is $4,750, a reasonable level for an especially attractive piece that is near finest known. Sold by GFRC for $5000 in January 2025. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 50C 1877S Seated 1877-S
MS62
CACG
685215384

Gem $995 Steely Reflective Luster, Absolute Gem at Grade, Very Conservative CACG Grading. Ex. Spring Branch. This 1877-S Seated half is an absolutely gem at the CACG certified grade. Steely fields radiate glowing reflective luster when viewed under a bright light. The darker in-hand toning melts away and reveals center rose and peripheral blues on the obverse while the reverse transitions to center blue-gray with peripheral aquamarine-gold. A 10x located a few ancient micro ticks on the lower gown that are totally inconsequential given the magnificent originality and eye appeal. This piece is more than conservatively graded. Housed in new CAC Grading (2023) holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Seated 50C 1879 Seated 1879
MS65
PCGS
29975015

Gem $4350 New September 28! Gem Original, Well Struck. Ex. Emerald and Newtown Collections. The low-mintage, 1879-1890 runs are well known to Liberty Seated half and quarter dollar enthusiasts, and this 12-coin group might easily stand on its own as a "set within a set." The present example, from the inaugural year of this run, presents a thick skin of smoky grey patina with sea-green highlights in the protected areas. Steely, frosted luster creates swirling cartwheels, and the eye appeal is compelling. Stars are sharply impressed, while a few of the feathers on the eagle's left leg are soft. The CAC census notes 96 examples in all grades, with 33 coins finer. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval.
Seated 50C 1880 Seated 1880
PF65
PCGS
40781870

Choice HOLD
$2475
New September 28! Fully Struck with Dazzling Reverse Toning. Ex. Emerald Collection. Mintage of 1,355. The reverse toning of this well struck proof is dazzling with vibrant blue, purple and magenta toning above deep watery fields. The obverse toning is attractive with blue and magenta concentric rim toning with a lighter purple center.
Seated 50C 1881 Seated 1881
MS65
CACG
294426045

Choice $4995 10,000 Minted. Lustrous with Color. Just 10,000 minted. This coin was clearly saved soon after being minted and well cared for since. It is well struck with few marks of any consequence. Both sides have colorful toning over strong underlying luster. The obverse has toning around the rims and on the right field with blue, magenta, and yellowis hues. The reverse toning is especially attractive as you move towards the right where the deep blue and magenta toning turns into vibrant yellow, orange, and blue color that glows from the strong underlying luster.
Seated 50C 1881 Seated 1881
MS64
PCGS OGH
5169886

Gem $3950 Superb Toning; Gem Quality. This coin has spectacular multiculored toning that comes alive under a light. The fields are semi prooflike and have excellent luster. The strike is excellent and marks are at a minimum. Would grade substantially higher but for some small lines to the left of stars 11 and 12.
Seated 50C 1881 Seated 1881
EF40
PCGS
58320916

Choice $1495 New September 8! Just 10,000 Minted. Original and Nicely Struck. This is an attractive choice example of a low mintage late date Seated half in a very popular grade. The original medium grey surfaces are nicely struck. Some small ticks can be seen on both sides commensurate with circulation. This would make a nice addition to a circulated Seated half set builder.
Barber 50C 1892 Barber 1892
AU58
PCGS
27926917

Choice $850 New October 11! Near Gem. Excellent Eye Appeal. Excellent eye appeal due to the grey iridecent toning covering the frosty and highly lustrous surfaces. No mentionable marks other than one small horizontal scratch on cheek which keeps us from assigning a Gem rating.
Barber 50C 1897S Barber 1897-S
F15
NGC
8292202019

Choice $850 Scarce Date; Problem Free Original Grey Surfaces. Four of the seven letters of LIBERTY are full with BER being partial. There are no major distracting marks on this light grey coin. From arms length the obverse looks smooth, but a loupe reveals some smaller marks on the obverse. The reverse is gem quality.
Barber 50C 1900S Barber 1900-S
AU50
PCGS
53908878

Choice $725 Strictly Original Light Grey. The surfaces are light grey and unquestionably original.There are some small scattered toned over marks on the coin. Curiously, there is a die break from star 8 through star 13 and through the bottom of Miss Liberty's neck and ending at the B initial.
Barber 50C 1901 Barber 1901
AU55
NGC
127836010

Gem $750 NGC 3.0 holder. Superb Luster with Light Attactive Toning. Ex. Island Lake Collection. This AU55 in an old NGC 3.0 (1987-1989) holder is pretty clearly an AU58 in today's grading. Tremendous luster on nicely struck surfaces. Some original blue and copper toning adorn both sides. It is devoid of marks and handling lines. You are not going to see too many AU Barber halves look like this.
Barber 50C 1902O Barber 1902-O
VF30
PCGS
19678371

Choice HOLD
$360
New September 24! Near Gem. Strictly Original Medium Grey. No one is going to dispute the originality of this medium grey coin. The surfaces are smooth for a VF30. Putting together a strictly original VF set with this look is a tremendous challenge. In a PCGS Gen. 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
Barber 50C 1906 Barber 1906
AU58
PCGS
33316732

Choice $850 Beautiful Originality, Popular PCGS-AU58 CAC. An obviously original undipped coin with nice luster and color. Mostly grey with a bit of crusty toning over problem free surfaces.
Barber 50C 1907D Barber 1907-D
EF45
PCGS
32758883

Gem $450 New September 28! Strictly Original with Clean Surfaces. This is a strictly original coin. Uniform light grey surfaces show few marks anywhere on the coin. An exemplary XF45 that is perfect for the grade.
Barber 50C 1909 Barber 1909
AU58
CACG
264614661

Choice $795 Popular AU58 Grade. Decently struck with good luster for this popular AU58 grade. The rims are copper toned with the obverse rims being more deeply toned. The obverse has some scattered lines that are more prevalent on the left obverse field. The reverse is gem quality on its own.
Barber 50C 1915S Barber 1915-S
VF35
PCGS
64208290

Choice HOLD
$360
New September 24! Excellent Originality. Charcoal grey toning over clean surfaces. Just the way a Choice VF Barber half should look.
Walking Liberty 50C 1916D Walking Liberty 1916-D
MS65
PCGS
44394843

Gem $2850 First Year Denver Design Issue, Pretty Golden-Rose Shades, Gem Original. GFRC Cost Basis! - The 1916 Philadelphia and Denver struck Walking Liberty halves have comparable rarity in the higher Mint State grades. I could not resist adding this notable gem Denver example to inventory. A well frosted example with radiant luster and the expected cartwheels given a moderate golden patina that turns to rose closer to the peripheries. If luster and superb eye appeal are your cup of tea, this new offering might warrant a closer look. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CAC approval.
Walking LIberty 50C 1916D Walking LIberty 1916-D
MS64
PCGS
56076175

Choice $1800 Strictly Original with Some Color. This is a highly lustrous example of this first year coin. There is a pretty tinge of color between the mintmark and the date. The fields on both sides are quite clean.
Walking Liberty 50C 1918D Walking Liberty 1918-D
AU58
PCGS
40958474

Gem $2100 New September 28! Pastel Grey Toning. Dove grey with pastel shades of rose gold with scattered iridenscence. This gem Walker is not only pretty but is devoid of marks. Only slight weekness on Miss Liberty's head and the eagle's leg. Nice latiny luster throughout.
Walking Liberty 50C 1918D Walking Liberty 1918-D
AU53
PCGS
50626921

Choice $895 Nice Originality. Very smooth frosty grey surfaces. Much retained luster remains under the fully original slightly crusty surfaces. The usual weakness in the central obverse and reverse but little actual wear. Good detail and little wear on liberty's head and breast and the eagles wing feathers. An excellent candidate for a high grade circulated date set.
Walking Liberty 50C 1919S Walking Liberty 1919-S
AU53
PCGS
60189861

Choice $3850 Golden Toning. This beautiful coin has strong satiny luster and semi-reflective surfaces covered by pretty golden toning. The wear is light for the grade. A few very light lines on the obverse but the eye appeal is well above average for this tough date. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.3 holder (March to November 2005).
Walking Liberty 50C 1921 Walking Liberty 1921
AU58
PCGS
33597235

Choice $9250 Frosty Luster. This near gem has strong frosty luster cover the original obviously undipped surfaces. Mostly grey with the lightest golden toning. Only the lightest of marks with very few light lines. A very attractive coin.
Walking Liberty 50C 1921D Walking Liberty 1921-D
VG10
NGC
6616202015

Choice $625 Key Date, Natural Coin Gray, Choice Surfaces. GFRC Cost Basis! - The 1921-D and 1921-S are the unquestioned key dates within the Walking Liberty half dollar series. The 1921-D sports the lowest mintage of the series and is even rare in the lower circulated grades. GFRC located this perfectly original example at the Summer Baltimore show for inventory. One can never have enough 1921-D example in inventory, right? Surfaces are toned a natural coin gray. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Early Commems 50C 1937 Early Commems 1937
Antietam
MS65
PCGS
3472650

Choice $925 New September 8! Near Gem with Classic Original Tab Toning. Surprisingly Few Marks. Mintage of 18,028. For Civil War enthusiasts, this early commemorative was kept in its original holder for a long time as it has the classic tab toning for this issue readily seen. There are very few marks for this MS65 grade as the hair, foreheads and cheeks are unusally smooth for the grade. In a PCGS Gen. 4.0 (1998-2002) early blue holder.
Walking Liberty 50C 1938 Walking Liberty 1938
MS66+
NGC
6604045003

Gem $750 Gem Original, Cumberland County Collection.. Consignor Pricing Reduction! - This gorgeous 1938 half offers brilliant frosted luster and swirling cartwheels under a bright light. A fully struck specimen with deeply impress skirt lines, a high relief outreached hand and head that will please the most stringent strike fanatics. The pristine surfaces beg the question of why this "CCC" lot not certified to the next level. This is a compelling offering that warrants several bids to locate a suitable pricing level. CAC price guide is $685 at MS66 with an increase to $2250 in "7". Housed in new large font holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6604
Walking Liberty 50C 1941 Walking Liberty 1941
PF65
CACG
416744670

Gem $750 Super Flashy!.Excellent Mirrors. Conservatively graded by CAC as "only" a PF65, this coin is very flashy, well struck and displays more eye appeal than higher graded examples. The fields display deep watery mirrors throughout. In a CACG Witter Brick holder.
Walking Liberty 50C 1943S Walking Liberty 1943-S
MS65+
PCGS
82626992

Choice $375 New September 28! Original White. This undipped gem has excellent luster with some frost with some hints of prooflike reflectivity. Sone light toning attests to the coins originality.
Walking Liberty 50C 1946 Walking Liberty 1946
Doubled Die Rev
MS64
NGC
3406834080

Choice $1895 Frostly White Near-Gem. A well struck nicely frosted coin with only a few marks keeping it from a full gem grade. The doubling on this interesting variety is most prominent on E PLURIBUS UNUM.
Walking Liberty 50C 1946 Walking Liberty 1946
Doubled Die Reverse
MS65
PCGS
53634657

Choice $3150 New September 28! Well Struck with Easily Visible Reverse Doubling. This well struck example of this doubled die reverse is easily seen without a loupe. Doubling is seen on E PLURIBUS UNUM and at the tips of each wing feather. The obverse is mostly brilliant white with the top quarter of the obverse toned a light copper color. The reverse is fully briliant white.
1 Dollar
Seated $1 1866 Seated 1866
PF64
PCGS
45843645

Gem $8500 Strong Cameo. An undipped proof with strong cameo on both sides, especially on the reverse which in our opinion boarders on deep cameo. Light toning covers both sides but does not hide the strong mirrors. The hairline free surfaces are surprisingly undisturbed for a 64. We would rather sell this one to a collector rather than a crack out dealer so if you want it please order before Central States. When we saw this coin at the recent March Baltimore show, we knew we had to buy it since we couldnt put it down.
Morgan $1 1878S Morgan 1878-S
MS65
PCGS
44384326

Choice $495 New September 25! Near Gem. First Year Issue that is Well Struck with Excellent Luster. This first year of issue Morgan dollar has excellent swirling luster that is well struck. The obverse may be MS65 quality, but the reverse looks to be MS67 quality.
Morgan $1 1879CC Morgan 1879-CC
GSA Hard
MS62+
NGC
5906267001

Choice $10750 With Original Box and GSA Certificate. Frosty Semi PL Surfaces; Clean Fields. Humphreys Collection. Only a little over 4,000 1879-CC dollars were distributed through the GSA sales of the 1970s, and these coins represent the bulk of this Mint State survivorship for this issue. This is the second-rarest Carson City Morgan dollar, trailing only the famous 1889-CC. The present coin has excellent frosty prooflike luster. Strike sharpness is above average for the issue, and the fields are very clean for the modest grade. Light abrasions on Miss Liberty's face account for the grade. Comes with the original box and original GSA certificate worth a few hundred dollars by itself.
Morgan $1 1879CC Morgan 1879-CC
AU58+
PCGS
52687291

Gem $12750 Pop 3 in AU58+ with Tremendous Toning. Ex. James A. Stack. We've seen a lot of 1879-CC Morgan dollars, but never with this kind of double sided intense target toning. A picture cannot begin to tell the story of this coin. This coin demands to be twirled under a light to see the magnificent toning. As part of the James A. Stack collection, this coin sat untouched for about 70 years. There is some rub on the center of the eagle on the reverse to justify the grade.
Morgan $1 1879S Morgan 1879-S
MS67
PCGS
44684329

Gem $1450 New September 28! Frosty Surfaces, Very Clean. A superb gem! Blazing luster with hints of orange-gold toning at the obverse periphery and in Miss Liberty's hair. Some frost on the devices creates exceptional eye appeal.
Morgan $1 1880CC Morgan 1880-CC
8/High 7
MS65
PCGS
25529837

Gem $1850 New August 20! 8/High 7 Repunched Date, Gem Original, Steely Frosted Luster. A gem original example of the 1880-CC repunched date with an easily seen undertype 7 digit inside the second 8 digit. On this high-end example, the entire 7 digit can be seen in its most minute detail. A premium example with steely frosted luster and vibrant cartwheels along with well preserved surfaces. The luster is notably reflective under a bright light as the fields are covered with micro granular mint bloom. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
Morgan $1 1880S Morgan 1880-S
MS64 PL
PCGS
52755840

Gem $375 Very Flashy PL with Contrast. The mirrors of the field have no haze and provide nice conrast to the devices. This isn't too far away from being a DMPL.
Morgan $1 1880S Morgan 1880-S
MS67+
PCGS
58600813

Gem $1950 Flashy Luster and Very Clean. An incredible premium gem that displays a full strike and dazzling cartwheel mint luster. Subtle field reflectivity joins the frosty dominating appearance. Liberty's cheek and the fields are pristine.
Morgan $1 1880S Morgan 1880-S
MS67
PCGS
44567908

Gem $1300 New September 28! Superb Gem. Original uindipped white superb gem Morgan. The devices are frosty, especiallly the eagle, and the reverse fields are semi-reflective. Very attractive.
Morgan $1 1881CC Morgan 1881-CC
MS63
CACG
519749654

Choice $995 Frosty White with Clean Cheek. An attractive lustrous white coin in a GSA Hard Case with original box and certificate. The obverse has a clean cheek for an MS63 coin with luster grazes and light marks on the left field. The reverse on its own is at least an MS65. Just 296,000 1881-CC dollars were minted.
Morgan $1 1881S Morgan 1881-S
MS67
PCGS
43289757

Gem HOLD
$1300
New September 28! Exceptionally Clean. This superb gem is characterized by super clean undipped original surfaces. Red and gold iridescence at the left obverse creates beautiful eye appeal.
Morgan $1 1882S Morgan 1882-S
MS67
PCGS
44912423

Gem $1295 Highly Lustrous and Well Struck. Picking up this highly lustrous flashy coin, we thought this was an 1880-S or 1881-S dollar, but it is actually an 1882-S. The population of 1882-S dollars in MS67 or higher is less than half of either the 1880-S or 1881-S. It is blast white with no spots or any discoloration. Well struck on both sides with the smallest of marks that provides substantial eye appeal.
Morgan $1 1890CC Morgan 1890-CC
AU58
PCGS
27744078

Gem $825 Gem Original. Ex. Spring Branch and Watch Hill Collections. Partially mirrored fields are framed by russet rims, more deeply on the obverse. The eagle is exceptionally frosted, contrasting with surrounding prooflike surfaces. Swirling cartwheels remain, with superior luster for an AU58 example. A nice coin. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval. The CDN retail value is $422.
Morgan $1 1891CC Morgan 1891-CC
MS63
PCGS
42119705

Choice $1350 Well Struck and Original. A well struck example of this better date cc morgan. The obverse of mostly white with a touch of gold in the left obverse while the reverse shows more of the same toning. Both sides have nice frosty luster.
Morgan $1 1891CC Morgan 1891-CC
AU53
PCGS
61862202

Choice $700 New September 28! Very Original; Clean Surfaces. Deep grey toning over very smooth mark free surfaces. Well struck and lightly worn, a lovely gem quality AU Morgan dollar of this popular Spitting Eagle variety.
Morgan $1 1893 Morgan 1893
EF40
NGC
3265449009

Choice $895 New September 28! Choice Original. Charcoal grey with deeper toning around the devices. Real luster can be seen notwithstanding the wear. A beautiful, original example of this better date.
Morgan $1 1895S Morgan 1895-S
VF35
CACG
26224928

Gem $1995 New October 11! Rare Date; Gem Original. Ex. Humphreys Collection. Another fantastic coin from the Humphrey's collection just back from CACG. Grey toning with deeper charchoal in and around the devices with plenty of remaining luster creates nice eye appeal. Good detail in the eagle's feather and wreath and Miss Liberty's hair and cheek, this one looks XFish. A few scattered marks and lines but the originality is unquestionable.
Morgan $1 1895S Morgan 1895-S
F12
PCGS
28914706

Gem $750 Gem Original. Ex. Spring Branch and Watch Hill Collections. This is precisely what an original, circulated Morgan dollar should look like, with lighter high points and contrasting shades in the recessed areas. The rarity of the issue (400,000 minted) only adds to the appeal of this CAC-approved example. This piece exhibits gray shading throughout, with reddish overtones additionally present on the obverse. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
Morgan $1 1898S Morgan 1898-S
AU58
PCGS
47531318

Choice $435 Attractive Slider, Steely Radiance, Vibrant Cartwheels, Light Gold Patina. Another better San Francisco strike that has been carefully handled with limited rub on the cheek. Under the desk lamp, steely radiance is noted along with swirling cartwheels. The cheek is unblemished and pleasing. A well balance Morgan that is worthy of a CAC only collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CAC approval.
Morgan $1 1899O Morgan 1899-O
MS64
PCGS OGH
7562221

Gem $450 OGH. Eye Appealing Blue and Magenta Obverse Toning. Ex Seal Beach. In a PCGS Gen. 3.1 (1993-1998) OGH holder. This lustrous nicely struck example shows beautiful blue and magenta toning throughout the obverse. Accurately graded as MS64, the reverse is flashy white.
Gold
Gold G$1 1855
Type 2 Indian Princess
MS61
PCGS
45679465

Choice $1950 Challenging Type 2 Indian Princess, Soft Frosted Luster, Premium Example, Evergreen State Collection. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2026) holder with CAC approval. Full description shortly.
Gold G$1 1873
Type 3 Indian Princess
MS63
PCGS
56482617

Gem $4500 New September 28! Prooflike and Cameo. Deep green gold toning over prooflike fields. Frost on Miss Liberty and the eagle gives the coin a cameo effect. Light lines on the delicate fields accounts for the grade. A beautiful gold dollar.
Gold G$10 1850
Liberty
AU55
PCGS
25618372
Large Date
Choice $3350 Choice Original. Ex. Spring Branch and Wisconsin Gold Collections. Residual luster lies in the protected areas of this Large Date example, contrasting with the minimally abraded fields. Surfaces are somewhat reflective and the overall flash is pleasing for the grade. Copper patina is occasionally evident, most noticeably at star 1. Stars are softly impressed, while a few of the claw joints exhibit separation, if faintly so. The CAC stickered population is 45 coins, with only four pieces at the Mint State level. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval
Gold G$10 1851-O
Liberty
EF45
NGC
1809172001

Choice $3495 Great Color, Original. The first thing one notices when viewing this coin is its blatantly original surfaces. Excellent surface life gives this coin the look of a higher grade. The color is beautiful. A few small marks keeps this one from a gem rating.
Gold G$10 1855
Liberty
AU58
PCGS
46565964

Choice $8500 New August 22! Near Gem. Strictly Original and Highest Graded Gold CAC. This is what strictly original gold looks like. Greenish gold with extremely few noticeable marks on the coin. The only more visible mark seen is in the field above Miss Liberty's head near stars 9 and 10. This is the highest graded Gold CAC for the date. From the Fairmont group.
Gold G$10 1888-S
Liberty
MS63
PCGS
51001741

Gem $3850 Excepional Luster. The first thing one notices when looking at this coin is its exceptional nearly prooflike luster. Add to that the great obviously original color, hammered strike and absence of any significant marks, this coin would not be out of place in a 64 holder.
Gold G$10 1891
Liberty
MS64
PCGS OGH
6549510

Choice $12500 OGH. Tied for Highest Graded with CAC; Beautiful Original Color. Near Gem. If you want to learn what strictly original gold looks like, this is it. Excellent luster under deep orange toning. With a mintage of just 91,820, this coin in an OGH PCGS Gen. 3.1 (1993-1998) holder becomes difficult in MS63 CAC and very difficult in MS64 CAC with 3 CAC endorsed in this grade with none finer. A few obverse marks keeps this from grading MS65, but the reverse on its own is MS65.
Gold G$10 1901-S
Liberty
MS64+
PCGS
35160254

Choice $3600 Choice Original, Brilliant Frosted Luster. Ex. Spring Branch and City by the Bay Collections. Lustrous yellow gold surfaces greet the viewer of this frosty San Francisco piece. Detail is sharp throughout, with individual feathers and claws easily distinct. Scattered contact marks are consistent with the grade, and the overall eye appeal is wholesome. The CAC price guide value is $2,950 in MS64 and $4,700 in MS65. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$10 1906-D
Liberty
MS62
NGC
3219079014

Choice $2995 Well Struck of this First Year of the Denver Mint Issue. Frosty golden-orange surfaces with a full strike and strong eye appeal. The 1906-D is the first Denver Mint eagle, and has a generous mintage of 981,000 pieces. This eye appealing coin would make a great addition to a mintmarked gold type set or specialized Liberty Head eagle collection.
Gold G$2.5 1861-S
Liberty
VF30
PCGS
42682987

Choice $2795 New October 1! Low Mintage of 24,000. Smooth and Attractive. Smooth mark free surfaces are graced by pale yellow toning. A tough date with only 24 stickered in all grades with only 11 higher.
Gold G$2.5 1862-S
Liberty
F15
PCGS
44693986

Choice $3150 New August 22! Strictly Original Rare Date with 8,000 Minted. This Civil War date had a tiny mintage of just 8,000. Only 18 have been endorsed by CAC at any grade. It is strictly original with pale reddish yellow coloration. The surfaces display excellent luster for the grade. Some marks can be seen in the left obverse field. The reverse is gem quality.
Gold G$2.5 1901
Liberty
MS65
PCGS
81986960

Gem $1350 New August 15! Gem Yellow Gold Surfaces. Well Struck with Booming Luster. Ex. Oregon Beaver. This gem quality late date liberty quarter eagle has flashy yellow gold toning, excellent booming luster and minimal marks. Well struck with an obverse luster graze between stars 5 and 6. The reverse displays a die break above STA in STATES. It would make an excellent type coin.
Gold G$2.5 1905
Liberty
MS64+
PCGS
81623025

Choice HOLD
$1025
Near-Gem Original, Rich Satiny Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, CAC Approval, Evergreen State Collection. The 1905 quarter eagle certainly brings on the eye appeal given its rich satiny luster that glows under the desk LED lamp. Cartwheels are consistent with full gem grade along with attractive honey green-gold coloration. Strike is 100% complete. This piece has the "look" of a gem but a single faint line in the right obverse field precludes that certification. MS64+ rewards the visual appearance. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$20 1874
Liberty
AU55
NGC
3815795010

Choice $5495 New September 29! Strictly Original Type 2 Liberty $20. This is a nice Type 2 Liberty $20 for a type set. The mintage of the 1874 is 366,780 which is considerably less than the 1873, 1874-S, 1875-S, and 1876-S which each had mintages above a million. Strictly original with some abrasions in the left obverse and Miss Liberty's cheek, otherwise the fields are clean. The reverse is gem quality.
Gold G$20 1907
Liberty
MS63
PCGS
16077891

Choice $5750 Smooth Lustrous and Original Liberty $20. Wonderful originality for this Choice BU with no major marks. It is decently struck with original luster.
Gold G$20 1924
St Gaudens
MS63
PCGS Rattler
5074659

Choice $5450 Rattler with an Original Reddish Orange Hue. Delightful reddish orange originality on this common date St. Gaudens $20 in a PCGS Gen. 1.2 (1986-1989) rattler holder.
Gold G$20 1927
St Gaudens
MS64
NGC
105618021

Choice $5195 Nice Originality in an NGC Fatty Holder. Marks are at a minimum on this original $20 Saint in an old NGC Fatty Holder.
Gold G$5 1842-D
Liberty
AU53
CACG
814931011

Choice $7995 New September 24! Small Date. Nice Color and Originality. The original orange gold surfaces have nice luster and only small scattered marks. Overall, this coin has excellent eye appeal.
Gold G$5 1852
Liberty
AU58
PCGS
52719505

Choice $2250 New September 29! Choice Original. An undipped original No Motto $5 with slightly dirty green gold luster. Only a hint of wear on well struck surfaces. An excellent type coin.
Gold G$5 1857-S
Liberty
AU55
CACG
119652479

Choice $4950 New September 24! Frosty and Clean. Ex. Fairmont. The honey gold surfaces are smooth and lustrous with a bit of frost. Combined with a sharp strike and minimal marks, this coin has excellent eye appeal. The label indicates it is a (L)egacy submission crossed from a PCGS Fairmont holder.
Gold G$5 1864
Liberty
AU50
PCGS
43083689

Gem $26500 New September 28! Civil War Rarity with Just 4,170 Minted. With a mintage of just 4,170, PCGS estimates that just 65 examples exist in any grade. CAC has endorsed 16 examples including 3 in AU50 and ten graded higher. On top of being a rare date during the Civil War, the originality and nice surfaces of this gem quality example would be tough to improve upon.
Gold G$5 1871
Liberty
AU58
PCGS
45172528

Choice HOLD
$9600
Low CAC Pop. Pop Top. Beautiful color.. A glance at the CAC pop report shows that Liberty half eagles from the Phildelphia mint are significantly underrated compared to their mint marked counterparts. This gorgeous 1871 is one of six AU58 stickered at CAC with none higher. The total CAC pop is only 11. Compare this to the 1871-CC half eagle that has a total CAC pop of 42, but which is priced at more than 7 times as much. This example not only has beatiful color but is minimally marked and has nice luster. A near gem which should be seen to be appreciate.
Gold G$5 1876-S
Liberty
EF40
NGC
4483507005

Choice $9500 Tough Date with only about 100 Known. This is one rare Liberty half eagle with an estimated 100 known in any grade. The coin has an attractive orange glow with only scattered marks. This is one of just two at this grade level with a CAC sticker with just four higher. With a CPG Value of $9,750, this is a reasonably priced example.
Gold G$5 1880
Liberty
MS64
PCGS
37765546

Choice $2100 Slightly Better Date in MS64. This coin gets tougher at the MS64 level. The luster is good with some weakness seen in Miss Liberty's hair and the eagle's neck and at the nock of the arrows.
Gold G$5 1891
Liberty
MS64
PCGS
41436481

Choice $3100 Rare Uncirculated, Superb Rose-Gold Coloring, Completed Strike, Near-Gem. GFRC Cost Basis! - 1891 Philadelphia $5 gold strikes were limited to 61,360 pieces in an era of massive silver coinage output. Most survivors are found with abrasions and/or light wear. At the MS64 level, this grade becomes rare and even more so with CAC approval. PCGS has not certified a single gem specimen, therefore MS64 and MS64+ graded examples are as good as it gets. GFRC is pleased to be offering one of the MS64 certified survivors that also has CAC approval. An infrequently seen rose-gold coloring is consistent on both sides. Bright light inspection is a joy given the brilliant frosted luster that explodes off the surfaces. Strike is 100% complete and rounds out the checklist for a designating this offering a near-gem. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2021) holder. Previously sold by GFRC during June 2021 for $4350.
Gold G$5 1899
Liberty
MS64
PCGS
83574788

Choice $1700 Near-Gem, Satiny Luster, Fully Struck, Pleasing for Type. Ex. Spring Branch. This 1899 half eagle was struck from worn dies with heavy metal flow lines resulting in satiny luster and gentle cartwheels. Strike is complete with abrasions being consistent with assigned grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$5 1903-S
Liberty
MS64+
PCGS
32800793

Gem $2250 Gem Original. Ex. Spring Branch and Wisconsin Gold Collections. Exceptional luster flows from the surfaces of this San Francisco five, and the GFRC Gem rating is no surprise, given the in-hand pop of the flashy fields. Even yellow-gold color blankets both sides, interrupted only by a few ticks that are consistent with the MS64+ technical grade. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$5 1912
Indian
MS63
NGC
6453767003

Choice $2350 Great Type Candidate, Steely-Frosted Luster, Honey-Gold, Well Preserved Surfaces. 1912 dated Indian $5 gold is known for its sharp luster and strong strikes. Yet another Summer Baltimore addition, this honey-gold colored example fits the bill. The obverse is pristine while there is one mark at the upper left reverse that is evident in the images. A premium example that is offered at a completive price to the CAC price guide. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
World
There are currently no coins for sale fitting this criteria.