Shield, Libery V & Buffalo Nickels

To Order: Contact Matt (917-727-1893) or Darrell (929-322-4953) by phone, or email using the shopping cart ()

There are 4 Coins for Sale. New coin(s) added on March 3, 2026

Photo Date Grade TPG GFRC Rating Price Description Buy
Shield Nickels
Shield 5C 1881 1881
EF40
NGC
3746119020
Choice $825 New February 19! Semi-key Date. Just 68,000 business strikes were minted of this scarce date. It displays nice originality with a smooth evenly worn obverse. The reverse has some older scattered marks in the open field surrounding the 5 and near the last A in America.
Liberty V Nickels
Liberty V 5C 1886 1886
G6
CACG
973638654
Choice $225 New March 3! Semi-key Date. The second best date of the Liberty nickel series, this coin has few hairlines for a coin that has circulated this much. The details are strong for the grade. There are some marks on the coin.
Liberty V 5C 1908 1908
PR67 PCGS
48240574
Gem $1245 Superb Eye Appeal, Sharp Watery Mirrors, Gem Original. Final GFRC Inventory Sale! - This colorfully toned 1908 Liberty proof nickel was recently taken in trade and is guaranteed to please fans of beautifully toned type coins. The GFRC accurately illustrate the rose, blues, and yellow orange-gold toning on the obverse and blended orange and light greens on the reverse. The watery mirrors are quite compelling under a bright light. The strike is fully executed with pristine fields as one would expect at this lofty grade. Hurry on this offering as I doubt it will be around after the Winter FUN show. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder.
Liberty V 5C 1909 1909
PF67DCAM
PCGS
53985613
Gem $9500 New February 19! A Flashy Deep Cameo Highlight. The picture speaks for itself with wonderful contrast between the fields and devices! You would be hard-pressed to find a more attractive example. At PCGS, there are two graded Proof 67DCAM and two more graded Proof 67+DCAM. At CAC, there are three stickered as Proof 67DCAM and one graded by CACG as Proof 67+DCAM.
Buffalo Nickels
Buffalo 5C 1914S 1914-S
MS63
PCGS OGH
4723122
Choice HOLD
$625
New February 26! Purplish Toning in OGH Holder. Purplish toning on both sides of this better date Buffalo nickel enhances the eye appeal. The strike is moderate for the date and the small marks blend into the design well. Housed in a PCGS Gen. 3.1 (1993-1998) OGH.