Shield, Libery V & Buffalo Nickels

To Order: Contact Matt (917-727-1893) or Darrell (929-322-4953) by phone, or email using the shopping cart ()

There are 6 Coins for Sale. New coin(s) added on October 11, 2026

Photo	Date	Grade	TPG	GFRC Rating	Price	Description	Buy
Shield Nickels
	1881	EF40	NGC 3746119020	Choice	$825	Semi-key Date. Just 68,000 business strikes were minted of this scarce date. It displays nice originality with a smooth evenly worn obverse. The reverse has some older scattered marks in the open field surrounding the 5 and near the last A in America.
Liberty V Nickels
	1886	MS63	PCGS OGH 7264188	Choice	$2700	New October 1! OGH. Well Struck and Lustrous. One of the three best dates in the Liberty nickel series. Well struck, lustrous with few marks. The grade is limited by a series of mint made planchet imperfections on the lower half of the obverse. Without the planchet imperfections, this coin would certainly grade higher. In a PCGS Gen. 3.0 (1990-1993) OGH holder.
	1909	PF67CAM	PCGS 50062136	Gem	$2750	New August 19! Attractively Toned on Both Sides.. It is unusual to find a nicely toned Liberty nickel with a cameo designation. The rims have bluish toning while the center is magenta on both sides. The toning doesn't impact the deeply mirrored fields that contrast nicely with Miss Liberty. Hairlines are not to be found. In a PCGS Gen. 4.1 (2002-2004) holder.
Buffalo Nickels
	1914-D	AU58	CACG 53871921	Gem	$650	Strictly Original and Nicely Struck. Few Marks. The 1914-D Buffalo nickel is one of the best dates in a circulated Buffalo nickel collection. This coin is strictly original and perfectly graded. It is nicely struck and has very few marks for an AU58. This kind of quality in an AU58 is hard to find which is what we seek relentlessly. The CACG holder does have some haze near LIBERTY on the obverse.
	1937 Three Legs	VF25	CACG 533236419	Gem	$1400	New October 11! Fantastic Eye Appeal; Popular Three Leg. Ex. Humphreys Collection The three legged Buffalo is as popular as ever. This CACG VF 25, just back from grading, is original as they come with great surface quality and a toning pattern which brings out all the design elements which are well struck. Almost medallic in appearance, this coin has excellent eye appeal.
	1938-D D/D	MS68	NGC 5845794004	Gem	$5950	New September 28! Attractive Toning for this Ultra High Grade Buffalo. The NGC Population is 17 with 2 graded 68*. This is an ultra high grade Buffalo with attractive toning. The obverse is purple and magenta in the recesses of the Indian head and obverse fields. The reverse is toned yellowish orange with some green visible. This coin is unusually clean with just about no marks seen. For the collector that demands the very finest.